Thursday, 09 February 2012

Refurb for the masses

A north London flat in a Victorian house is the scene of a pilot experiment to see if eco-friendly refurbs can be achieved at mass-market prices. Philippa Ward paid a visit

Refurbished flat

What Refurbishment of the 600 square foot, one-bedroom empty ground-floor flat of a Victorian terrace house to 80 per cent carbon dioxide reduction

Where Islington, north London

Who United House and Islington Council

How much £21,865

How long Six weeks

The only thing visibly special about the house I am visiting in Islington, north London, is that Arsenal’s stadium towers at the end of the road. For football fans, this would be a good spot to hear the roar of the crowd every other Saturday. For anyone else, it might be a bit of a nightmare.

However, the sound proofing on the ground floor flat of this house has just got a little bit better, with state-of-the-art vacuum sealed windows and quality insulation cutting out some of the roar of the fans. 70a Aubert Road has had an eco-makeover and better insulation was top of the list.

For social housing contractor United House, the flat is the first step towards becoming expert in eco-refurbishment. It decided to take an ordinary Victorian house in Islington undergoing decent homes work and take it to the next stage: a green overhaul.

Projects like this are springing up all over the country but Alistair Sivill, the technical director at United House working on the project, claims this one is different. ‘Others have thrown money and bling at it but we want to become the Henry Ford of this, doing it for sensible prices,’ he explains.

So if United House can mass-produce green refurbishments the way that Mr Ford produced millions of cars, how will it go about making it affordable?

There is a chart pinned up in the living room showing the measures that give the greatest savings of carbon dioxide for the cheapest price. Top of the list is low-energy lighting, while a heat-recovery system that recycles waste heat loiters at the bottom. ‘We’ll work our way down the list to get to the budget total,’ says Mr Sivill.

The idea is that a social landlord with a set pot of money will be able to get the most bang for its buck if it refurbishes its whole stock. Such a project would aim to cut carbon-dioxide emissions from houses as much as possible, but not all homes would get the same treatment - only the changes that are most cost-effective. The cash would go where it can achieve the largest carbon dioxide reduction per pound spent.

The conclusion drawn from this flat, which is on the bottom floor of a Victorian conversion, is that a 50 per cent cut is easy to achieve, a 70 per cent cut is quite costly and an 80 per cent cut unfeasibly expensive. Given that the government has pledged to slash carbon dioxide emissions by 80 per cent by 2050, that sounds like bad news. But Mr Sivill’s view is that cost-effective action now is more important than aiming for an impossible target: ‘It’s 2010, 2012, 2014 that matters - not 2050.’

What’s more, the team at United House stacked the odds against themselves. ‘We chose a property that is hard to heat - this is as difficult as it gets to improve,’ says Mr Savill. The company’s next challenge will be even tougher: in the coming months, hard-to-treat units will be retrofitted with tenants already in place.


Walls

Solid walls have been insulated with just under 30mm of Aerogel with an air gap. The floor has been sealed with 150mm of Warmcell insulation. The airtight breathable membrane has been brought up above the skirting board to avoid heat loss.

‘Magic wallpaper’, which has insulating properties, has been put in the hall, because it must not be made any narrower. There is no benefit to the flat itself in treating the ceiling or party walls because the next door and upstairs properties benefit from carbon savings.


Windows

The wooden sash windows are being kept, but the glass has been replaced with Japanese-made vacuum glazing with a 20mm gap between the double sheets of glass.

Brushes to exclude draughts have been added to the windows of the front of the property. These work better than the mastic tried on the ones at the back.


Water

There is a 100-litre rainwater tank in the bathroom, with mains back-up. However, as Mr Sivill points out, if rainwater harvesting becomes popular then the leaseholder upstairs will get to it first. The bath is average size and, surprisingly, there is no shower - the work on the fixtures and fittings is only the standard for decent homes.


Energy

The flat has a micro-combined heat and power unit in the form of its Baxi boiler, which is fuelled by gas and generates both heat and electricity. This boiler is part of a field trial, one of 80 such boilers in the UK, and will be launched at the end of the year. Mr Sivill thinks that if there was a feed-in tariff it would generate at least £100 per year for the tenant.


Air tightness

Tests revealed that the flat measured 9 on the air pressure rating compared with a legal maximum of 10 for building regulations. The team was aiming for a low 5 but managed to get 7. The real results, however, will only be as eco-friendly as the tenants living there, so United House has come up with guidance to help tenants live greener.


Skills

The building team got a ‘toolbox talk’ before work started, to explain the theories behind the eco-refit. They learned that they needed to change their way of thinking because air-tightness has to be considered at all times, so patching up problems is no longer an option. ‘It is an attitude change and won’t be easy,’ says Mr Savill.

Key lessons

1. Heat recovery systems, where waste warmth is sucked out of the kitchen and bathroom and fed into the living room and bedroom, are more trouble than they are worth in retrofitted houses.

A 200mm suspended ceiling had to be put in to hide the pipes, which cost a lot but won’t save that much heat in comparison with the money spent.

It also meant adding a huge unit the size of a tumble drier to the kitchen, which any prospective tenant is unlikely to be delighted with. ‘It is ideal for new build, but not existing stock,’ says Mr Sivill. ‘That was a mistake, but it’s why we did the pilot.’

2. ‘Next time, I would use more offsite modern methods of construction and do a more accurate survey to start with,’ says Mr Sivill, who thinks it would save time and give a closer fit on the insulation, cutting down heat loss.

It would also hopefully prevent unforeseen problems such as the dust that started to fill the air as soon as they began to cut up the insulation onsite.

IMPROVEMENTCOST (£)KILOS OF CO2 SAVED£ PER KILO OF CO2 PER YEAR
Set thermostat at 20 degrees C instead of 21 degrees C01300
Reduce hot water use by 10 per cent0330
Low-energy lighting45900.50
Draught proofing windows6502822
Replace Band G with Band A fridge3001003
Baxi micro CHP (including 10 years’ maintenance)4,7501,3004
Replace Band G washing machine with Band A300764
Double glazing (4.37m2 vacuum)6001006 (50% saving)
Insulate external walls Aerogel 23m24,4706237
Insulate floor (29.4 m2)3,7001406
Insulate party wall ‘magic wallpaper’ 14m21,6504140
Heat recovery ventilation (including 10 years’ maintenance)6,0007086 (80% saving)
Overall (excluding tenant action items)21,8652,6468

Readers' comments (1)

  • This is a first class cost/benefit piece of work which could be be used to feed us further information. I would like to see a cost effective shower unit put in and would also appreciate some information on the utility costs before and after the re-fit- ie what are the annual savings in pounds sterling from a fe-fit of this nature from the tenants point of view.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say

You must sign in to make a comment

sign in register

Related

Articles

  • Research uncovers green deal limitations

    17 November 2011

    The government’s flagship energy efficiency scheme will only fund a small proportion of work to improve homes without subsidy, according to research.

  • Hybrid approach passively helps achieve 70% energy reduction in retrofit for the future

    8 June 2011

    Innovative ventilation technology from Passivent is helping one social housing provider refurbish its homes to achieve a 70+% reduction in energy consumption.

  • Sustainable Housing Awards 2011

    04/11/2011

    With the green deal approaching, the use of pioneering eco-technologies in housing is more important than ever before. Here Chloë Stothart reveals the housing providers, developers and architects leading the way

  • Testing technology

    09/09/2011

    The government spent £17 million testing cutting-edge green technology in preparation for widespread retrofitting of the UK’s homes under the green deal. So what did it learn? Mark Wilding reports

  • Tenant attitude a boon for retrofits

    28/04/2011

    John Barnham makes a very valid point in his letter about tenant education going hand in hand with energy efficiency improvements (Inside Housing, 8 April). Behavioural change is fundamental to making retrofit investments worthwhile.

Resources

  • Health check

    04/11/2011

    Can living in an energy-efficient home improve residents’ well-being? Gentoo’s latest retrofit pilot aims to find out. Martin Hilditch reports

  • Scrapheap challenge

    20/01/2012

    The price of metal has risen sky high making pipes, railings and even boilers an irresistible target to thieves. Chloë Stothart finds out how one housing association is tackling the growing problem of metal theft

  • Cracking the glass ceiling

    11/02/2011

    Women are well represented in the social housing industry - but only up to middle management level. Lydia Stockdale reveals the results of Inside Housing’s exclusive women in housing survey and finds out what’s holding them back

  • Green guru

    09/09/2011

    Social landlords must ask themselves now how they will access green deal cash and whether energy company obligation funding can help, says Sally Hancox

  • Along for the ride

    27/01/2012

    Contractor Kier offers customers the chance to shadow a maintenance worker for a day. Here, Sheffield Homes tenant Yvonne Collins, 71, explains how the scheme is improving tenants’ understanding of repairs and their satisfaction with the service

Latest Jobs

  • Group Director of Finance

    An exciting new opportunity for a Group Finance Director has arisen following a major merger announcement in the North West ...

    £74,500 to £91,000

    Closing: 2012-02-16 00:00:00

  • Director of Customer & Community Services

    Yarlington has 9,000 homes across the South West. Our employees tell us its a great place to live and work. ...

    c.£85k plus PRP, car allowance, final salary pension

    Closing: 2012-02-10 00:00:00

  • Director of Development & Property

    Yarlington has 9,000 homes across the South West. Our employees tell us its a great place to live and work. ...

    c.£85k plus PRP, car allowance, final salary pension

    Closing: 2012-02-10 00:00:00

  • Community Sustainment Co-ordinator

    Established in April 2007, Rykneld Homes is North East Derbyshire district council's housing management organisation responsible for the management, maintenance ...

    £27,849

    Closing: 2012-02-27 00:00:00

  • Anti-social Behaviour Officer

    As part of our hard working and dedicated team, you’ll play a key role in ensuring our tenants feel safe ...

    £22,283 - £28,590 + 10% car allowance

    Closing: 2012-02-18 00:00:00