Tuesday, 07 February 2012

Immigrant figures are correct

The publication of the report on immigrants and housing by the Equalities and Human Rights Commission led to letters from John Pankhurst (Inside Housing, 17 July), questioning its conclusions.

The Chartered Institute of Housing was also party to the original work, commissioned by the EHRC and the Local Government Association in 2008. Like the researchers from the Institute for Public Policy Research, whose findings Mr Pankhurst questions, we also reached the conclusion that new migrants form a very small proportion of those getting new lettings in social housing.

Mr Pankhurst says the statistics are ‘misleading’, but they come from the Continuous Recording System returns from housing associations and local authorities and can be seen on the CORE website.

We looked specifically at migrants from the new EU member states. Last year, they made up less than one per cent of new lettings and the most recent figure shows that this has hardly changed. Overall, foreign-born applicants make up less than 5 per cent of lettings, and most of these are not recent migrants.

Indeed the IPPR showed from the labour force survey that less than 2 per cent of social tenants are people who have arrived in Britain within the last five years. Some of these are likely to be to refugees, who are not allowed to work (in most cases) until they are given refugee status. This means they are unlikely to have the money to put down a deposit for a private-rented flat, much less to buy a house.

If Mr Pankhurst and other correspondents think these figures are wrong, why do they suppose that social landlords are supplying inaccurate information for their CORE returns?

John Perry, policy adviser, Chartered Institute of Housing

Have your say

You must sign in to make a comment

sign in register

Related

Articles

  • Migration of truth?

    23 August 2011

    MigrationWatch is at it again, with a claim that meeting the social housing needs of new immigrants will cost the taxpayer £1 billion a year for the next 25 years.

  • ...not according to our research

    15/04/2011

    In our paper Choice-based letting ethnicity and segregation in England we investigated lettings data using rigorous statistical techniques.

  • Broaden your horizons

    18/11/2011

    Landlords can learn valuable lessons by looking abroad, says Richard Kemp

  • Forward thinking

    27/01/2012

    This year’s UK Housing Review by the Chartered Institute of Housing takes a look at how coalition government policies are affecting housing trends. Here, Hal Pawson, Steve Wilcox and John Perry give the lowdown on the report

  • Between a Rock and a hard place

    01/04/2011

    A Cornish town is overcoming inflated house prices by letting locals build their own affordable homes. Jules Birch asks whether the new community right to build will make this type of resident-led development easier.

Resources

  • Wind of change

    05/08/2011

    A host of new laws are set to change the landscape for Welsh social landlords. Michael Northcott reports

  • Keep things in proportion

    08/04/2011

    After Pinnock landlords could face more court cases as short-term tenancies are introduced, says Kate Thompson, solicitor at Eversheds

  • Calm down

    25/03/2011

    There’s no need for housing associations to panic about losing their charitable status, says Keith Jenkins

  • Sheltered lives

    09/09/2011

    Care providers must demonstrate they have acted fairly when changing services to avoid costly legal action, says Robert Wassall

  • Dealing with disputes

    15 August 2011

    The standard process for resolving construction disagreements isn’t always the most appropriate, explains Tom Wrzesien, a dispute resolution specialist at law firm TLT