Monday, 06 September 2010

Helen Giles

Expert opinion

Failure to take up adequate employee references can prove disastrous in the long term

Most people working in the housing sector are talented and committed individuals driven by positive values. However, there is a minority for whom this is not true.

Through a combination of slack selection procedures and negligence in pre-employment screening, we persistently let them into our organisations.

Even though there is no better predicator of future effectiveness than how people have performed and behaved in the past, we shy away from asking searching questions of their ex-employers. Then we’re surprised when our organisations are turned upside down and our service-users shafted by the mad, bad and dangerous to know.

Stop me if you’ve heard this one…
There are tales aplenty of poor recruitment choices: how about the housing officer who, after three years in employment, is discovered never to have done the visits or racked up the expenses they’ve claimed, but who takes out multiple grievances when caught bang to rights. Or the manager who doesn’t manage so chaos rules supreme in their department.

Or, indeed, the waking nights worker who brings in their pillow to bed down for the night after they’ve filled their cars with their employers’ cleaning products and plenty of headed paper on which to print out fake references for their friends. Bullies, thieves, predators, toxic moaners, absentees - the list goes on and on.

The reasons we don’t reference properly
We want people in the door quickly and references take too much time. We don’t believe other employers will really be truthful about people anyway because if they’re bad they’ll want to pass them on or they’ll be too frightened of litigation to spill the beans. We’re liberal people in the business of working with the dispossessed and are squeamish about seeking or acting on information that prevents us giving people another chance. The age-old protocol of asking people to cite two people as referees, asking them not very searching questions, and then failing to act on the information when we get anything bad back is the way it’s always been done and nothing else seems quite cricket. Despite the evidence of who and where it gets us.

How to do it right
Make referencing the job of one or two people who have the focus and are trained to spot the scams. Ask loads of questions, including brief comments against crucial competency areas such as customer focus and team working.

Check the provenance of every reference - does the organisation actually exist and was it given by someone authorised to provide references? Go for at least five years’ worth of history.

If they’ve had eight jobs in that time go for every one but sign off once a consistently glowing picture renders pursuit of the final few unnecessary.

Make sensible adjustments to this rule for individuals who haven’t had a long work history such as homeless people or recent graduates.

If any reference is less than glittering, phone up the referee to get to the bottom of any faint praise.

If you find anything at all with a whiff about it, don’t appoint the candidate. That ‘minor’ issue alluded to by the referee could well turn out to be a major problem.

Helen Giles is managing director of Broadway’s Real People HR consultancy

Readers' comments (1)

  • Maybe you've had some bad experiences in the past but I think you're being a little paranoid.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say

You must sign in to make a comment

sign in register

Related images

Related

Articles

  • Be the best

    30/07/2010

    When it comes to cutbacks, middle managers are often first in the firing line. Helen Giles advises on how to ensure you keep your job

  • The green life

    11/09/2009

    We’re all in favour of eco-homes, but do they change lives? Simon Brandon visited some residents of green homes and asked them to spill the beans

  • Internal issues

    30 September 2009

  • The right to homes

    30/04/2010

    Barking and Dagenham is a key election battleground in Labour’s campaign to see off the far right British National Party. Caroline Thorpe visits the east London borough to uncover housing’s role in the fight.

  • The missing piece

    11/12/2009

    From 2015 all social housing built in the UK must reach a zero-carbon standard - but when is the government going to clarify exactly what that means? Philippa Ward investigates

Resources

  • The dawn of a new era

    04/06/2010

    What details should we look out for in the new legislative programme?

  • Commencing countdown

    05/02/2010

    The Tenant Services Authority ignites into action on 1 April, so what should councils and ALMOs do to prepare? Greg Campbell and Tony Hirsch explain

  • The view across the fence

    28/05/2010

    Employment tribunals are on the rise. Here two specialist lawyers in the field explain the process for both the employer and the employee

  • Put it in the diary

    28/05/2010

    The Labour government passed a record 4,300 laws between 1997 and their defeat in this month’s general election. And there are a few more in the pipeline, still to be passed. Here is the key legislation to look out for alongside some important cases that could have serious legal implications for housing in the UK

  • Court in middle

    30/04/2010

    Landlords seeking evictions are in a difficult position as judges decide which court does what, says Ian Larkins

Latest Jobs