Friday, 19 December 2014

What is the difference between a Secure and Assured Tenancy

Posted in: Need to Know | Ask the Experts

21/07/2010 4:47 pm

Unsuitable or offensive? Report this discussion

Sort: Newest first | Oldest first



22/07/2010 1:54 pm

Hi Reuben

I am not a legal expert, but I would of thought that if your Council home was taken by Housing Trust you would have retained your Secure Tenancy, and not Assured Tenancy.

One way to ascertain this is to check whether you are covered by the "Fair Rent Act"  (which was abolished by the Tories in the late eighties).

ie: do you have your rent assessed annually by a Fair Rent Officer at your Local Authority?

There are limited differences between Secure  and Assured Tenancy though, other than your housing trust can charge "market Rents" for your home therefore, much higher rents than when covered by the Fair Rent Act.

Hope this is helpful

Kindest regards

Roger P Murphy

Unsuitable or offensive? Report this reply

Kev Dupree

Kev Dupree

Posts: 25

29/07/2010 4:00 pm

Hi reuben,

As roger says i would be surprissed that if you had a secure tenancy before the take over, why you would now have an assured tenancy? It may be worth querrying this with your landlord as secure tenancies have slightly more rights.

The main ones being assured tenants do not have the right to buy, but instead have the right to acquire (this may not be important due to the length of time you have been in the property) Right to aquire is not as attractive as the discounts offered as less than those for RTB.

There are also some more suitable differences, succession for example. An assured tenant can only be succeeded by their spouse whereas a secure tenant can be secured by any member of the family (as long as they have lived with them for a year)

Assured tenants also have less rights in relation to lodgers and a few other minor issues.

In general a secure tenancy would be preferable from a tenant's point of view as it offers more rights.

I'm unsure about your "service" charge issues, hopefully someone else can help you with this aspect.

Unsuitable or offensive? Report this reply

john williams

john williams

Posts: 629

30/07/2010 2:24 pm

A good aspect of secure tenancy is that the landlord can only put up the rent every 2 years, instead for assured tenancy I am told it is every year.

Looks like secure tenacies have been stopped and assured tenancies borught in to rip off tenants increasing the rent every year.

Tenants sould campaign to bring back secure tenancies, at least for tenants who have been living in the same property for some time.

It is unaccceptable that even residents living 30 40 years and more in the same property should not be secure tenants.

I think every tenants who has lived in the same property for at least 4 years shouold be automatically made secure tenant.

Unsuitable or offensive? Report this reply

Expert post

Abimbola  Badejo

Abimbola Badejo

Posts: 120

02/08/2010 3:49 pm

The Housing Act 1985 makes clear that for a tenancy to remain a secure tenancy, the landlord and tenant condition must be satisfied. The landlord condition is that the landlord must be a one of the prescribed public sector bodies. Once the landlord ceases to be such a body such as when the ownership of the property changes from a local authority to a housing association, the tenancy ceases to be a secure tenancy and becomes an assured tenancy.
I have experience of the housing transfer process which is is known as a stock transfer. For a stock transfer to go ahead, the secretary of  state must approve the transfer. The secretary of state will not approve the transfer unless satisfied that in effect the majority of secure tenants who vote are in favour of the transfer. In order to get a positive ballot, what normally happens is that the incoming landlord makes certain promises to the existing secure tenants. The most significant promise is that so far as possible, the existing council tenants are to retain most of their rights after the transfer to the new housing association landlord. For example council tenancies have a right to buy their property. Assured tenants do not. However in the new tenancy agreement to the new assured tenants following the transfer, the right to buy is preserved. Council tenants also have a right to pass their tenancy on during their lifetime but assured tenants do not. This right is preserved in the new tenancy agreement given to  former secure tenants when they become assured tenants. Other matters such as repairing obligations, remain the same irrespective of whether the landlord is a local authority or a housing association.
So you are in law an assured tenant and you need to check your tenancy agreement to ensure that your landlord is allowed to levy the charges you have mentioned. I suspect that the tenancy agreement will allow them to impose such charges. Most of those tenancy agreements tend to provide that the landlord will consult with tenants before introducing new charges so check  your tenancy agreement to see what it says on this issue. In respect of your shower, I suspect that the association are carrying out decent homes works which involves refurbishing bathroom and kitchens. I am sure that some landlords have a policy that they will not force tenants to have new baths or showers where tenants do not want one unless there are health and safety reasons why the bathroom needs to be changed. So please raise that with your landlord.

Unsuitable or offensive? Report this reply

Rate this topic

  • 1 star out of 5
  • 2 stars out of 5
  • 3 stars out of 5
  • 4 stars out of 5
  • 5 stars out of 5

You must be signed in to rate.

Post a Reply

You must sign in to rate this topic or make a post

sign in register

Why not register?

Registration allows you to sign up for newsletters, comment on articles, add posts in the forums, quiz our panel of experts, and save articles and jobs in the My IH section.

Register now

Newsletter Sign-up

Most active members

Most recent posts

  • posted Anonymously, 18/12/2014 1:52 pm in Death, Secure Tenancy, Downsizing and relatives moving in

    I lived with my mother for over 20 years in a 2 bed council flat. My mother sadly passed away 3 years ago. The council got in touch with me about 6 weeks ago and requested verious bills, death certificate, etc as proof that I lived there so that I would get succession in tenancy which I am entitled to. However, they have now said that I need to downsize. This is my home and the thought of having to move away from friends and family is making me ill. I have no one else in the area and am getting ill over this. ...

  • posted Anonymously, 13/12/2014 5:01 pm in Shared Ownership and extending the lease

    Hi Again

  • From Zoheb Chaudhry, 27/11/2014 10:10 am in damp/ mould

    Hello there dawn,

  • From Zoheb Chaudhry, 27/11/2014 9:49 am in Damp,mould and disrepair- Professional Advice Please

    Hello there,

  • posted Anonymously, 24/11/2014 4:58 pm in Couple one over 65 bedroom tax advice

    I am over 65 and live in a small council flat. I suffer from spinal arthritis as well as other health problems. I have decided to swap my flat with a housing association tenant whose flat is slightly larger than mine I.e an extra small bedroom. I am looking ahead as I may eventually be confined to a wheel chair. I have been told that I would not have to pay the bedroom tax.  I live on my own and would be living on my own if the swap goes through. Does anyone know if I have to pay ...

  • From My own private domicile, 24/11/2014 4:36 pm in Mutual Exchanges

    The legislation that you're looking at relates to statutory overcrowding, you're looking at Part X of the Housing Act 1985.  Mutual exhanges are in s.92, which is Part IV. 

  • From given up , 21/11/2014 7:07 pm in Service Charge Increase Legal? Moral?

    Its all over..Nottingjham Community Housing Association have successully had my cl;aim  for comepsanation for failing to provide the standards of care and support expected in their sheltered housing scheme thrown out on a legal technicality! . What a Farce. Social Housing? I dont Think So..and i have to pay half their  costs!

  • From Sarah Adams, 16/11/2014 3:46 pm in Is there an obligation to carryout gas & electric safety checks on Mutual Exchanges

    I do apologise if I am interupting anyones conversation (first time using this website)

  • From Paul Kennedy, 12/11/2014 6:11 pm in Is a Housing Association / Housing Co-operative tenant

    One point worth mentioning - a tenant who owns property elsewhere will not be entitled to Housing Benefit.

  • From Dawn Young, 26/10/2014 4:34 pm in temporary decant

    I am in a hotel i cant get it re directed here i asked.

IH Subscription