Monday, 30 November 2015

Human rights ruling halts eviction

Councils could face increased pressure not to evict tenants who go into arrears after a Supreme Court ruling.

Hounslow Council tried to evict Rebecca Powell, 23, because she owed more than £3,500 in arrears. The council had housed her in temporary accommodation after she became homeless in April 2007.

She was entitled to £15,000 in housing benefit but had not applied for it properly.

The council began eviction procedures, but stopped when Ms Powell appealed under the Human Rights Act.

The Supreme Court ruled last week that under the European Convention on Human Rights it would be wrong to evict Ms Powell as it would be a breach of ‘respect for a person’s home’.

The judge said the council had not considered whether it was ‘proportionate’ to evict her.

Last week’s hearing follows on from the Pinnock case last year. This ruled courts should test the proportionality of landlord’s decision to carry out mandatory possession proceedings, taking into account a tenant’s personal circumstances.

A spokesperson for Hounslow Council said: ‘This is an evolving area of law. Hounslow argued this case and its position was vindicated as evidenced by the results in both the county court and Court of Appeal.

‘Judgement in the case of Pinnock was handed down on 3 November 2010 and set binding precedent. Ms Powell was heard on 23 November 2010 and on the advice of counsel, alternative accommodation was provided to Ms Powell to limit costs and avoid the necessity of a rehearing in the county court.

‘Hounslow Council and no doubt other councils will be concerned about the implications of this case in terms of the management and allocation of its housing resources.’

Ms Powell has agreed to clear her debt at a rate of £5 per week, or more if possible.

Readers' comments (43)

Comments are only open to subscribers of Inside Housing

Already a subscriber?

If you’re already a subscriber to Inside Housing, your subscription may not be linked to your online account. You can link your subscription from within the My Account section of the website and clicking on Link My Account.

Not yet a subscriber?

If you don't yet subscribe to Inside Housing, please visit our subscription page to view our various subscription packages.

Have your say

You must sign in to make a comment

sign in register

Newsletter Sign-up



  • Refurbishment contract ruling boost for landlords

    31 July 2015

    Social landlords could make significant savings on refurbishment works, following a landmark legal ruling freeing them to enter into more cost-effective contracts while recovering service charges from leaseholders.

  • Landlord defends planned commune eviction

    3 July 2015

    A housing association has issued a lengthy-defence of its decision to move out residents of ‘communes’ in London, claiming it is simply ‘carrying out its responsibilities as a landlord’.

  • Right to Buy policy 'could spark human rights challenge'

    15 April 2015

    The extension of Right to Buy to housing associations could result in a lengthy legal battle on human rights grounds, legal experts say.

  • Pickles halts Winchester development

    16 February 2015

    A controversial development in Winchester where a commitment to provide 40% affordable housing on-site was unlawfully dropped has been put on hold by Eric Pickles.

  • Pickles 'breached Gypsy and Traveller human rights'

    21 January 2015

    Eric Pickles broke equality laws by calling in planning decisions regarding Gypsy and Traveller sites that fall within the green belt, the High court has ruled.

IH Subscription