Monday, 02 March 2015

Benefit levels

Posted in: Need to Know | Ask the Experts

02/02/2012 10:14 am

Unsuitable or offensive? Report this discussion

Sort: Newest first | Oldest first

Author

Message

Anonymous

Anonymous

20/02/2012 9:49 am

Rick 4:41 am

"Some interesting points made in the various posts but nobody has really answered how much a person should have to live on (excluding housing costs).

IS £40-53 emough then?"

Have you ever thought of asking your Housing Association Ceo or director or any Housing Association ceo or director?... If, for example and example only, suddenly he or she is sacked (for drugs dealings or incompetence or any other very serious matter) and all his or her assets are seized, how much would he/she need to live on?... I think he or she would find your guess of £40-53 pw quite offensive.

Unsuitable or offensive? Report this reply

mfm

mfm

Posts: 37

20/02/2012 9:55 am

I answered it! 

In London £8.30 per hour.
Outside of London £7.20

As I say, these figures are based on research into minimum income standards and still don't leave any leeway but let people get by without getting into debt and ill health where possible.

And to remind anyone that wants to criticise these figures as absurd - this is based on research conducted with the British public.

Having said all that, I still couldn't live on those amount and many others wouldn't so it just shows just how little some people have to live on..

Unsuitable or offensive? Report this reply

F451

F451

Location: Banished from free speech
Posts: 192

20/02/2012 10:20 am

Cause for celebration - Rick is still with us.

I'm so pleased to know you are still in the land of the living Rick. I was honestly beginning to fear the worst, and such a loss that would be.

I was also hoping you'd be back on-line before I put out my flame at the end of this week (other time demands arising for a while, but then the odd alter-ego will still be able to pop up every now and again, and I did announce that this hot little chap could only ever last till Spring - well the bulbs are coming up in Somerset at least!)

Thanks for making my week already Rick, simply by still breathing!

Unsuitable or offensive? Report this reply

Rick Campbell

Rick Campbell

Location: Macclesfield CHESHIRE
Posts: 424

20/02/2012 2:42 pm

Anon at 9-44am -- the Chief Exec tells me that he puts a lot more in his car a week than £40-53 ... we had the conversation about 3 weeks ago.

Anon at 9-55am-- I saw your amount but then as I was asking about benefits for the disabled and those not working then at an hoursly rate, they'd get nowt.

C233 -- very kind of you to say so -- my minders were doublful as to whether I was fir enough to return just yet but as I was at the pub (with goddaughter -- who is a 'minder' and granddaughter -- who has become a 'minder') they didn't need much convincing but in exchange I have to keep to a strict regime. If the worse came to the worst then there would be info put on here by minders.

Unsuitable or offensive? Report this reply

F451

F451

Location: Banished from free speech
Posts: 192

20/02/2012 3:06 pm

May your minders begat further minders who too begat minders of their own, until their enough minders to get rid of the bloody Arthur Daley figure pretending to run the country!

[tell your minders they are very special people, and much loved for all that they do.]

Unsuitable or offensive? Report this reply

Rick Campbell

Rick Campbell

Location: Macclesfield CHESHIRE
Posts: 424

20/02/2012 3:21 pm

Unfortunately or fortunately the two (of eight) minders will not be begatting in the biblical sense for diverse reasons BUT without my cajoling have come to the same conclusion about the government -- neither of then have voted before (one 'couldn't be bothered' and is 21 a week today whilst the other was 18 last month).

They will both be voting next time round -- they will vote for whoever but the 3 main parties do not figure high on their list of favourites but are higher on their preferred lists than the extremist parties.

They are both popular, strong minded and intelligent vocal women with friends of a similar nature -- there's a number of them who will be voting for the first time next time round ... that's around 40 new votes not going to the sitting MP

Unsuitable or offensive? Report this reply

F451

F451

Location: Banished from free speech
Posts: 192

20/02/2012 3:50 pm

An interesting thought that when the sitting MP next comes to stand they may not be returned to sitting once more because of the poor standing the appalling position, that they fell in behind, gave them.

All that is needed is a cast iron pledge from any who are standing who, when sitting, may be held to and deliver in the interest of the everyday folk who entrusted them with their vote in the first place.

Perhaps this trusting to representatives has done its day and we should all just take power as Jono keep asking us to do, although who would look out for the less strong in that set up.

In the words of my election trainer many years ago - tell your voters to vote early and vote often!

Unsuitable or offensive? Report this reply

Rick Campbell

Rick Campbell

Location: Macclesfield CHESHIRE
Posts: 424

20/02/2012 3:58 pm

Methinx we had the same trainer or maybe we just happen to have a social conscience;

Back on topic -- if it is the case that a single pensioner needs £140 or so a week to live on, (EXCLUDING housing costs), it is perhaps reasonable for a similar sum to be required by a disabled person.

I heard a suggestion recently that a standard national rate should be set for housing costs at no more than £20 per bedroom additional to £100 for a 1 bedroom property.

Unsuitable or offensive? Report this reply

F451

F451

Location: Banished from free speech
Posts: 192

20/02/2012 4:12 pm

Perhaps looking it the other way around. If the government says it can not afford to pay the rent of someone such that they have more than £70 per week to live on how do they expect anyone, disabled or otherwise, to afford to pay the high rents the government are now sponsoring but will not make affordable. As rent is now the highest single element within a low income person's expenditure (just think, that used to be food, then fuel, then housing cost) then failing to enable a person to afford such a basic expense means that the person concerned will not be able to afford to live in this society.

Oddly, in a third world society, where fuel may be gathered for free, food may be gleaned from the countryside without landlowners demanding arrests be made, and housing may be self built without accusations of squatting or failure to pay the planning department enough, people can live on lower sums. Expecting people here to live on such sums is just not practical without also granting the freedom to return to being hunter gatherers as well.

Unsuitable or offensive? Report this reply

Rick Campbell

Rick Campbell

Location: Macclesfield CHESHIRE
Posts: 424

20/02/2012 4:41 pm

I wonder how governments figure out what people need to live on and if anyone knows where the data can be found, providing of course, that it is in an understandable form and easy to access.

Unsuitable or offensive? Report this reply

F451

F451

Location: Banished from free speech
Posts: 192

20/02/2012 5:28 pm

They gather together their pocket change at a cabinet meeting and then divide the sum by the number of unemployed, pensioners and persons with disabilities, subtract 50% to take into account single parents and those under 35, subtract 10% of the remainder for teas and biscuits (rechargeable of course), and then the resulting figure is the daily sum for an average family of four to live on.

To get the individual person rate, simply deduct the current child benefit payment value and then divide by 100 and times by 65 to get what an individual needs.

However, it must be noted that the contents of Mr Pickles pockets are for the exclusive use of those who are poor but located in Birmingham.

Unsuitable or offensive? Report this reply

Rick Campbell

Rick Campbell

Location: Macclesfield CHESHIRE
Posts: 424

20/02/2012 5:35 pm

Apparently the £40-53 is because the amount cannot be more than 60% of the amount the government says is needed to live on.

A fortnight previously, the tenant was allowed £89-99 to live on with lower projected expenditure on gas for heating.

I just can't work the maths out  -- but then, I'm not an acolyte nor an apologist!

Perhaps if claimants prayed before evey claim then things would work better.

Unsuitable or offensive? Report this reply

View results 10 per page | 20 per page | 50 per page |

Rate this topic (5 average user rating)

  • 1 star out of 5
  • 2 stars out of 5
  • 3 stars out of 5
  • 4 stars out of 5
  • 5 stars out of 5

You must be signed in to rate.

Post a Reply

You must sign in to rate this topic or make a post

sign in register

Why not register?

Registration allows you to sign up for newsletters, comment on articles, add posts in the forums, quiz our panel of experts, and save articles and jobs in the My IH section.

Register now

Newsletter Sign-up

Most active members

Most recent posts

  • From F451, 24/02/2015 4:38 pm in Query re RTB and affordable rent

    It would be so great to be allowed to discuss things in these areas again.

  • From Alan Ward, 23/02/2015 7:30 am in SECURE TENANCY

    Can housing association change my secured tenancy from a 2 bed to a 1 bedroom. I have complained for 15 years that my 15 year old bedroom is to small. Only can fit a single bed. That's all. Now they admit it's a 1 bedroom and want me to change my tenancy to a 1 bedroom also I have paid rent for 15 years and they say they owe me no arrears is this Legal?

  • From Alan Ward, 23/02/2015 7:23 am in Tenant's right to withdraw notice

    Hi. Can any one advice please. 15 years ago I swapped my 2 bed flat in Norwich to a 2 bed flat in Wimbledon. When I moved hear I questioned my then housing officer that the single bedroom was to small. After 15 years the housing associtation now say it's a 1 bedroom even though I have been paying for a 2 bedroom. Also they want me to change my secure tenancy from a 2 bed to 1 bedroom contract and tell me they owe me no arrears of rent. Is this legal?

  • posted Anonymously, 29/01/2015 8:09 am in Homeless occupant not being assisted by council

    Hi MFM.

  • posted Anonymously, 29/01/2015 8:08 am in Rehousing Of Council Tenant

    compenstion - yes, ask them.

  • From Rexroth, 19/01/2015 6:50 pm in To what extent can a RSL advise residents on financial matters.

    They need a licence.

  • posted Anonymously, 15/01/2015 11:17 pm in forced to end assured tenancy to start a joint one

    Can I ask as to how she is forcing you out? Has she asked you to leave or has she ended the tenancy? 

  • From Alan London, 13/01/2015 6:11 pm in Relationship break down and moving out with housing association tenancy

    Thanks. No info on the website regarding assignment or succession but in the tenancy agreement it only refers to the subject when talking about the death of the tenant. My partner is still quite young and although it would be nice to have the ability to assign...if it exists, there are other questions to be considered. Her job is not secure and she has been told that if she should need to claim housing benefit in the future then she would only be able to claim for half the rent should my name still be on the tenancy. Were ...

  • posted Anonymously, 05/01/2015 9:27 am in Housing Officer issues

    Hi Andrew,

  • From Rose007, 21/12/2014 4:22 pm in Death, Secure Tenancy, Downsizing and relatives moving in

    I advise you to seek proper advice on this.  There are many people that provide advice on this site that is not necessarily correct.  Have you now succeeded to the tenancy or is that still being looked into.  The Localism Act introduced further rules relating to succession.  caselaw is Newport CC v Charles considered by court of appeal.  The son kept up a pretence his mother was still alive when she had died a number of years previous.  The initial court hearing granted possession under Ground 16 which was overturned on appeal as more than 12 months had passed ...

IH Subscription