Wednesday, 23 May 2012

Board member pay

Posted in: Need to Know | Focus

05/02/2012 8:41 pm

Unsuitable or offensive? Report this discussion

Sort: Newest first | Oldest first

Author

Message

Anonymous

Anonymous

05/02/2012 8:57 pm

Better results can only come with the democratic election of board members, without so called boards made up of friends or nodding horses tenants... If on top of that you pay them they will be even more friendly and the nodding hourses syndrome will be even more accelerated. 

Unsuitable or offensive? Report this reply

SteveGough

SteveGough

Location: Southampton
Posts: 5

06/02/2012 10:32 am

Anon : Do you mean that all Board Members should be elected, or a proportion? Also, I think I know what you mean about 'nodding horses' but could you expand a bit? If your experience is that Board Mmebers simply accept what the mamagement team want without debate then I cam see the justification for a sceptical view. If they debate the points fully and end up agreeing that's a different thing.

Unsuitable or offensive? Report this reply

Anonymous

Anonymous

07/02/2012 1:32 am

Well, SteveGough what his your experience in this?... I have been a tenant for 30 years and I NEVER come across a situation in my HA where a board member has been democratically elected by other tenants.  They have seemingly been opted on the basis that "they could work with the board."  Which means they had either to agree to whatever the so-called board said or would be left out in to cold and made to resign.  this has engendered a culture where tenants have come to believe that the best way to get something out of their landlord is be nodding horses and nodding dogs, ei, never complain or challenge anything. this in turn means that things will never change and things will be run as they have always been run and if you dare to say anything different you are just a troublemaker who cannot work with the board.

  

Unsuitable or offensive? Report this reply

F451

F451

Location: Europe
Posts: 181

07/02/2012 2:48 pm

Board Members are recruited in a number of ways.

Some are directly recruited. They need to apply and meet the recruitment criteria, attend for interview, even pass tests, before being accepted following such a competitive exercise.

Some are directly elected. They need to apply and meet the recruitment criteria (which may be more tenant centered and less business centered than the directly recruited members, although equally they can be the same), attend for interview, and in the instance that there are more qualifying than there are positions, either face election or another round of interview.

Some are appointed as political representatives from the local council, or as corporate representatvies from a parent body.

Some are co-opted to offer the Board expertise that they would otherwise lack.

All should be accountable however, and tenants should know who is on the Board through which method, what their roles are, and how they may be contacted.

Board Members should definately recieve expenses back, but as for direct payment that is for the corporate body to decide. The 'shareholders' - that is the tenants - should be the greater proportino of the corporate body in such a decision.

Unsuitable or offensive? Report this reply

SteveGough

SteveGough

Location: Southampton
Posts: 5

07/02/2012 5:59 pm

Anon : Since you ask my experience in housing started as a member of a self help housing co-op so my bias will always be for people to have an active say in how their housing is run. As it was student based I couldn't stay forever and ended up in the same city but working in housing for the next 20 years for various landlords.

I became a board member when the university where I taught CIH Housing Professional courses received a letter asking if anyone would like to apply. 

As F451 says theree are numerous ways in which tenants can end up on Boards, but I think you are being very harsh in your condemnation of board members. Of course my complete ignorance of your HA's set up probably helps!

Unsuitable or offensive? Report this reply

simon ryan

simon ryan

Location: am a highly involved tenant wi
Posts: 41

10/03/2012 8:41 am

i have just resigned as a customer board member of my H/A, the actual position was ok but things changed so much from when it was first advertised  as a new concept i found i had problems with my own personall morals  , i took the position as non paid and then arfter several goal post changes i found i wouldnt really be involved with tenants ,ide just be decideing on H/A  policies ,thats not me ime a foot soldier in the tenant world , unfortunatly i did find going from a forum to a board ,my so called friends all turned on me because there egotistic way got hurt when they didnt get a position , still you soon learn who is an involved tenant and who is there really for there own gratification ,there own ego and how much they can rip there H/A{but really the tenants } of , the concept of a non paid board is 1 of the best things ive seen come into the social houseing market , but the top boys wouldnt except a non paid member  so i choose to mleave ,no ill feeling ,no disgruntled blow the whistle feelings

just a plain ,"I am a foot soldier and i prfer to be where i fit and can do best , ON THE FROMNT LINE ,,, so to all you people within our H/A froums ,,that tried to blacken my name ,  2THE POSITION IS NOW OPEN " but i hope and pray that you lot from the old boy net work never get picked because it will be the end of good old tenant participation and become a board of egotistic ,selfish ,money and credit grabbing biggots ,,, then we will have a collapse  of tenant involvement and tenant gorvernance

Unsuitable or offensive? Report this reply

simon ryan

simon ryan

Location: am a highly involved tenant wi
Posts: 41

10/03/2012 9:20 am

i would like to add to my statement above as this is a topic about pay or no pay ,,i joined as anon paid memeber ,but a board higher up than ours decided we had to take pay if we acepted chair/vice or portfolios to work on and my moralls kept saying inside me ," i got into tenant involvement because i wanted to help promote my H/A, my fellow tennants and anyone else that wanted to get involved as  a non paid volenteer , there was several who applied just cause they thought they would earn from it ie- payment,ego credit ,little perks that other tenants may have to wait for ,,, i am PROUD that these were not my reasons but sad that the goal posts moved so far i couldnt perform to my best , luckily for my fellow tenants the members left on my board are the perfect mix , but when they advertise my ex posittion i am worried that a lot of the nasty back stabbers will get a position on the board  therefore undoing the work my H/A has done and destroying the good nature of those still left on the customer board i was part of

DONT LET THEM DESTROY YOU FOLKS , ,YOU ARE THE FIRST LINE OF TENANT PROTECTION

Unsuitable or offensive? Report this reply

Colemankim14

Colemankim14

Posts: 20

10/03/2012 3:35 pm

Simon like I was to to become a Customer Board Member and that what I saw people they for own ego's and want to rub shoulders with the hierarchy wasn't they for Tenants

Also I noted that the Resident Group and Group Board loyal was to the Association, Mangement and no one checking this fact figures  and also sitting on Stage Three Hearing Local Area Group has Chairs and Vice Chairs and none have been democratically elected by other tenants.

So cannot turn to TSA they and the Government Eroding our Rights 

Unsuitable or offensive? Report this reply

Colemankim14

Colemankim14

Posts: 20

10/03/2012 3:42 pm

No I do not believe Board Members should be paid due to the fact chartiable

Unsuitable or offensive? Report this reply

Colemankim14

Colemankim14

Posts: 20

10/03/2012 4:00 pm

Simon I hope the old boy's network will never be picked because it is the end of Tenant Involvement the board our self and money making bigots

Yes we all know that want Tenant Involvement to collapse unless you are a Nodding Dog, Horse

Well up from the ashes the Phoenix will rise of Tenant Independant Group liken to Tower Hamlet Federation

Unsuitable or offensive? Report this reply

simon ryan

simon ryan

Location: am a highly involved tenant wi
Posts: 41

10/03/2012 4:30 pm

i believe customer boards if put in place as they are originally concieved are a great concept but with mine i started on a football pitch and closed my eyes for a second and when i opened them it had become a rugby field

i think its up to the individual as to the payment issue ,it wasnt what i joined for and on top of goal post changes i decided it wasnt for me ,,

ime a active involved tenant foot soldier i create ideas to improve tenants lifes ,i act on them and i get a buzz out of seeing tenants get what they need and are entitled to out of mine and my forums actions ,this is the life i choose to be in and enjoy ,

i also respect those who can sit at a table and decide things to improve a tenants lot , the people left on my board are all 100% capable of doing that ,, the fear is now ive left all the ego heads will try to get my place and destroy the people left bit by bit to turn it back to old boy net working ,and even if the H/a isnt happy to go along with it they will have to just to tick goverment boxes  

Unsuitable or offensive? Report this reply

Anonymous

Anonymous

10/03/2012 4:49 pm

Amenable, Compliant Tenants

Unsuitable or offensive? Report this reply

Colemankim14

Colemankim14

Posts: 20

10/03/2012 4:55 pm

Yes Simon they want to be box tickers for the government and sell they souls that they problem.  We have no other way of gettng involved.  We  have no way of contacting the Board  or its Customer Chair's or Vice Chair's and Minutes of Meeting not pubished and we cannot the Involvement Manager to adhere

Unsuitable or offensive? Report this reply

simon ryan

simon ryan

Location: am a highly involved tenant wi
Posts: 41

10/03/2012 5:03 pm

 coleman i feel for you ,i am lucky that the county i am in is made up of people who wont allow that to happen to us , amenable compliant tenant ime not ,

ime willing to agree to try any progress that anyone wants to but what i wont let happen in my world, if i can stop it ,is a bunch of bullies no matter if they are a H/A, ,an ego head or an outside influence , take me and fellow tenants for a ride that has no basis of truth ,honesty or progresion contained within it ,, just there own personal gratification ,,     

thats a ride i would never sign up for   

Unsuitable or offensive? Report this reply

Colemankim14

Colemankim14

Posts: 20

10/03/2012 5:31 pm

Simon me neither i am a foot soldier like you.  I wish others realised. What a hard task we have.  The Snapps of the world does not realise that it a up hill struggle with no real scrutiny 

Unsuitable or offensive? Report this reply

Rate this topic (5 average user rating)

  • 1 star out of 5
  • 2 stars out of 5
  • 3 stars out of 5
  • 4 stars out of 5
  • 5 stars out of 5

You must be signed in to rate.

Post a Reply

You must sign in to rate this topic or make a post

sign in register

Why not register?

Registration allows you to sign up for newsletters, comment on articles, add posts in the forums, quiz our panel of experts, and save articles and jobs in the My IH section.

Register now

Newsletter Sign-up

More Newsletters

Most active members

Most recent posts

  • posted Anonymously, 22/05/2012 11:24 am in Fuel poverty

    Let me first delcare an interest in this field. I work for one of the big six energy providers and am also a social housing tenant.

  • From Esther Sample, 09/05/2012 4:06 pm in Tackling domestic violence

    Good to see this topic being highlighted within the sector. Housing and domestic violence is becoming even more pressing with services at risk of losing funding and refuge provision being cut. Homelessness services face an increasing demand from people fleeing domestic violence, and in particular from women with complex needs such as substance use and mental health problems. Recent St Mungo’s research among our female residents revealed that 35 percent of women who had slept rough, left home to escape domestic violence.

  • From Matt Murdock, 03/04/2012 6:10 pm in HRA reform

    Very little change here. No plans for additional borrowing as we can't afford to repay more debt than we have (despite having the borrowing headroom).

  • From simon ryan, 28/03/2012 9:46 am in Building stronger communities

    hasnt any one realized you cant BUILD a community , they build there selves and that can only be done by the people within the area themselves , if an H/A tries to build 1 there is allways in the back of the minds of people participateing " oh yes what do they get out of it " , comunitties are built by moralls ,feelings and the understanding of everyone as to where the boundries are put by others ,,, a comunity BUILT, will eventually collapse a comunity grown will if allowed to continue will grow into what we all ...

  • From simon ryan, 22/03/2012 3:10 pm in Tenant panels

    yes anon i agree 100% with the staement concerning the betrayal of tenants needs and rights ,and thats not because ive just been betrayed { ime used to that } its because as you believe i also am like wise in my beliefs and unless we keep our rights to be that way we will all end up os being  walked round and treated like ever obediant puppies

  • From Colemankim14, 10/03/2012 5:31 pm in Board member pay

    Simon me neither i am a foot soldier like you.  I wish others realised. What a hard task we have.  The Snapps of the world does not realise that it a up hill struggle with no real scrutiny 

  • posted Anonymously, 05/03/2012 8:33 pm in Transparency

    They are not been  transparency what is happening is still management figures so again  no more no less.  No Tenants have been involved or Scrunity these figures

  • From Bill Pearson, 05/03/2012 11:30 am in Tenant cashback

    Over the 30 odd years I have been asocial housing tenant I have replaced skirting boards, architraves, doors including an outside door to an alleyway between the house and outbuilding for security and floorboards that should have been done by contactors when upgrading work was done. Plus pipe clips that were not fitted when the central heating was installed to name but a few. All his on a state pension.

  • From Bob Green, 29/02/2012 5:10 pm in LGBT housing

    Organisations should treat people as individuals. However, labels will allow us to find out how well, or how poorly, organisations are doing.