Wednesday, 23 April 2014

Charity warns ending homelessness prevention work will hit social services

Bristol mayor seeks to raid homelessness fund

A west country council is considering axing its own internal homelessness prevention budget next financial year in a bid to save cash.

Bristol Council is consulting on a plan to axe a £200,000 pot for homlessness prevention it uses to provide rent deposits and rent-in-advance loans.

The council received £1.3 million grant intended to prevent homelessness for the current financial year and has been allocated a further £1.1 million for the next. It has spent the 2012/13 grant, which is not ring-fenced, on services around homelessness prevention, and set up a smaller £200,000 pot to pay specifically for homelessness prevention services.

Under proposals tabled by newly elected mayor George Ferguson, the council would scrap its own internal prevention pot. The mayor has tabled the plan as part of an attempt to slash £35 million from the council’s £365 million overall budget for 2013/14.

Umbrella organisation Homeless Link warned the move would lead to a rise in homelessness applications and use of bed and breakfast accommodation. It also said pressure on social services would increase as homeless families and vulnerable people would find it hard to access private rented sector accommodation.

The organisation stated: ‘Investment in prevention services produces direct cost savings for local authorities, for example, through lower use of temporary accommodation and fewer social services interventions.’ (See box: The cost effectiveness of homelessness prevention).

The council, which has a housing waiting list of 17,000, has helped 4,000 people requiring homelessness assistance and advice in 2012/13, a 25 per cent increase on 2011/12.

Although the cut is not a done deal, because a cross-party working group set up by Mr Ferguson to look at the budget proposals has recommended the plan to scrap the prevention fund is not implemented.

The group calculated the cost of preventing someone from becoming homeless was £1,700 compared with the £5,300 cost of dealing with someone after they become homeless. The latter figure was based on research from Heriot-Watt University.

A spokesperson for Bristol Council said the Heriot-Watt research indicated the average cost of running a deposit bond scheme, where the council lends money for a rent deposit, was 37 times cheaper than the average cost of dealing with a statutory homelessness case.

He said the group considered using the prevention grant as ‘a cost-effective preventative measure’.

A final decision on the budget will be made at a full council meeting on 26 February.

The cost effectiveness of homelessness prevention

An advice note from Communities and Local Government department, Demonstrating the cost-effectiveness of preventing homelessness, published in 2010, outlines the cost savings of preventing homelessness:

  • The cost of mediation - for example, resolving family disputes to avoid someone becoming homeless - is nine times less expensive than finding someone new accommodation
  • Advice on housing options, such as how to solve benefit problems or helping people to manage their finances, is also estimated at around nine times less expensive than finding someone new accommodation
  • The costs of a rent deposit scheme are estimated to be eight-and-a-half times less than the costs of providing accommodation under the main homelessness duty.

Readers' comments (5)

  • Education is key.
    Pay rent first
    this would save the majority of benefit problems leading to eviction.
    Showing people how to manage their finances and benefits is vital to reducing the issues coming with UC

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Iron Fist

    Looks like Bristol intends to follow the lead set by Derby. How very far sighted and progressive. Muppets!!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • @dvdfrost

    Feeding and cloting kids, paying for heating etc. You wouldn't make those the top priority if you had minimal income and a partner who didn't let you have much cash would you?

    @Iron Fist - quite - some people really don't have a clue and will stoop to anything just to try and win their seat back at the next election.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • @foothpath

    Feeding and clothing children as weel as heating is more difficult if you are homeless. Having a partner who doesn't let you have much cash then you need to address that issue yourself.

    The proposal from Bristol is scandalous and is a false economy. For a council to take a homeless household through the process into finding them housing costs far more than the cost of preventing the homelessness in the first place.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • How exactly is this news? This has been going on at LAs since the government removed the ring fence from the funding. If they genuinely want it to be spent on homelessness prevention then why remove the ring fence and allow it to be swallowed up into Council's already over stretched budgets.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say

You must sign in to make a comment

sign in register

Newsletter Sign-up

More Newsletters

Related

Articles

  • Spending review – live blog

    26 June 2013

  • Bristol mayor shares dreams of homes

    27 March 2014

    George Ferguson wants Bristol to build homes - not houses. Jess McCabe finds out about his ambitious plans to deliver developments with a soul

  • Uncertainty looms

    7 January 2014

    The axing of the local welfare provision grant was an unpleasant ‘Christmas surprise’ but Scotland looks set to protect its version

  • Bristol announces biggest PV scheme since FIT cuts

    06/09/2013

    Bristol Council is planning a solar photovoltaic project worth up to £47 million to install panels on up to 7,000 social homes in the city.

  • No excuses

    2 July 2013

    The public need to persuade the government to do more to end youth homelessness, says Balbir Chatrik

Resources

  • Global reach

    09/08/2013

    Off on holiday this summer? Perhaps you’d prefer to spend a longer stint abroad? Here, Caroline Thorpe speaks to housing professionals based overseas about how their UK experience has gone down among employers on the other side of the world

  • Room for dignity

    14/02/2014

    A new toolkit aims to help smaller housing associations address the needs of residents suffering from dementia. Caroline Thorpe reports

  • Flexible friend

    31/05/2013

    A flexibuy tenancy scheme does comply with the Human Rights Act, says Helen Tucker

  • The price is right

    03/05/2013

    Legal reforms should reduce the cost of going to court, says Anna-Liisa Blanks-Walden, senior associate at Clarke Willmott

  • Making an impact

    10/05/2013

    Innovative landlords should not ignore social impact bonds, says Jon Coane, housing finance partner at Bevan Brittan