Tuesday, 27 September 2016

Borrowing caps will inhibit authorities’ ability to replace sold properties

Councils fear RTB won’t deliver homes

Fears are growing among local authorities that government plans to increase right to buy discounts will fail to deliver replacement homes.

A consultation on coalition plans to revitalise the right to buy in England was released before Christmas by the Communities and Local Government department, proposing a new maximum discount of £50,000. The previous maximum discount varied but was as low as £16,000 in some areas.

The consultation reiterated the government’s commitment to providing a new affordable rent home for each council home sold. However, some authorities have claimed government caps on borrowing would restrict their ability to replace stock.

‘If I had the [borrowing] headroom I would want to keep the receipts and build new houses, but I don’t have it,’ said Glyn Hall, head of housing at Durham Council.

The CLG’s impact assessment shows councils would need £40,000 to £50,000 in receipts from each home to fund a replacement. The average council stock price in some parts of the north is less than £70,000, which could leave councils with less than £25,000 in receipts to replace a sold home after other costs such as payment of historic debt are returned, forcing them to increase their borrowing.

‘It will be a struggle for many [councils] to make it work,’ said David Hall, a director at housing consultancy Sector. ‘There are issues that they [CLG] haven’t acknowledged around the borrowing cap.

‘Those authorities that want to do new build but are at or close to their borrowing cap will find it difficult to provide replacement homes without extra borrowing power.’

A CLG spokesperson said: ‘The receipts generated from right to buy will naturally vary between properties and places but we would expect landlords to deliver these new homes within their existing borrowing limits, working closely with partners including housing associations, and making best use of their own land, assets and other resources, instead of putting in capital or increasing borrowing.’

The consultation on right to buy closes on 2 February.

In numbers: right to buy

number of RTB sales targeted by prime minister David Cameron

£40,000 to £50,000
receipts required from each RTB sale to build a replacement home

council contribution per home to provide one-for-one replacements

estimated RTB sales in England in 2010/11

Readers' comments (8)

Comments are only open to subscribers of Inside Housing

Already a subscriber?

If you’re already a subscriber to Inside Housing, your subscription may not be linked to your online account. You can link your subscription from within the My Account section of the website and clicking on Link My Account.

Not yet a subscriber?

If you don't yet subscribe to Inside Housing, please visit our subscription page to view our various subscription packages.

Have your say

You must sign in to make a comment

sign in register

Newsletter Sign-up



  • Enfield scheme 'to deliver 10,000 homes'

    31 May 2016

    Enfield Council has announced that up to 10,000 new homes will be built as part of a £3.5bn Housing Zone development.

  • Councils spend £27m of RTB funds buying back homes

    11 February 2016

    Councils have spent almost £30m of cash raised through Right to Buy sales to buy back homes they were forced to sell at a discount under the same policy.

  • Thousands of homes face RTB exemption

    4 December 2015

    Housing associations could exempt hundreds of thousands of homes from the Right to Buy extension, including any built as a result of a planning obligation.

  • AHP set to deliver Starter Homes

    18 November 2015

    The Department for Communities and Local Government is expecting to shift some of the focus of its Affordable Homes Programme towards the delivery of Starter Homes, following next Wednesday’s Spending Review.

  • ALMOs and councils call for urgent RTB talks

    1 October 2015

    Arm’s-length management organisations and stock-owning councils have written to the communities secretary asking for urgent talks over the impact of the proposed Right to Buy extension on housing associations.

IH Subscription