Monday, 25 May 2015

20 councils accused of a lack of consultation in test case over care cuts

Court fight to keep live-in wardens

Residents of sheltered housing developments have begun a legal fight to retain their live-in wardens.

A solicitor for tenants of around 50 schemes in more than 20 local authorities has issued papers to bring a judicial review of the decisions or proposals to remove the wardens.

Yvonne Hossack served papers on Barnet Council on 4 September. The council plans to remove live-in wardens from some schemes and replace them with visiting staff. Bradford, Hackney and Devon councils, which have all removed live-in staff from some schemes, will also be challenged as part of the test case.

Ms Hossack said: ‘The court can see what happens in practice by having cases from people who have been without a warden for longest.’
Papers against the remaining councils will be issued this week. The cases are funded by legal aid.

Ms Hossack has also asked the court to consider an application to stop Barnet from making further changes to the service until the case concludes.She is waiting for a court date for the judicial review. Her assistant Louise Kirk said they would argue that the residents expected a live-in warden when they moved in and that there was a lack of proper consultation about a change to the service.

The Essential Role of Sheltered Housing, which represents sheltered housing landlords, said restrictions under the European working time directive made it difficult to employ resident wardens, some schemes struggled to attract live-in staff and some residents did not want them. Instead it backed visiting staff based on the needs of the residents.

Meanwhile, a disciplinary case between Ms Hossack and watchdog the Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal will be heard this week. Three councils against which she had brought legal cases over care cuts reported her, saying her standard of work must suffer because of the long hours she works.

Readers' comments (29)

Comments are only open to subscribers of Inside Housing

Already a subscriber?

If you’re already a subscriber to Inside Housing, your subscription may not be linked to your online account. You can link your subscription from within the My Account section of the website and clicking on Link My Account.

Not yet a subscriber?

If you don't yet subscribe to Inside Housing, please visit our subscription page to view our various subscription packages.

Have your say

You must sign in to make a comment

sign in register

Newsletter Sign-up



  • Keep moving


    Last month, housing professionals found their voice - but they’ve got to keep shouting

  • Landlords' plea to keep AHP grant


    Social landlords that will miss a ‘drop dead date’ for completing homes are locked in negotiations to persuade funding bodies not to deduct their grant.

  • Young people 'forced to live in unsafe housing'

    14 October 2014

    Young people leaving care are forced to live in ‘unsafe housing’ where they feel ‘lonely and scared’ and are at increased risk of homelessness, a report has said.

  • MP wants councils to keep register of self-build projects

    10 July 2014

    Councils would be required to keep a register of people interested in bringing forward self-build and custom-build projects, under a private members’ bill to be debated by MPs.

  • Council to fight fraud with ID cards

    10 July 2014

    A Gloucestershire council will issue tenant ID cards and keep photos on file

IH Subscription