Sunday, 20 April 2014

Housing associations introduce new clauses to stop abnormally low bids

Landlords crack down on ‘suicide-bidding’

Housing associations are including new clauses in tenders to try to prevent companies winning work with abnormally low ‘suicide’ bids.

A handful of landlords are understood to be using the clauses, which for the first time allow them to discard bids that fall below a specific threshold.

Poplar Harca has introduced a clause in tenders awarded as part of its £145 million refurbishment programme. The clause gives the 8,400-home association the right to ask contractors for evidence that the work can be carried out to standard if the bid is more than 10 per cent below the average. The clause says: ‘In the event that… the employer still considers a tender price to be abnormally low, the employer reserves the right to discount that tender submission.’

Although EU law allows businesses to reject abnormally low bids, it does not define ‘abnormally low’, which has lead to disputes with bidders.

Paul Dooley, director of estate regeneration at Poplar Harca, said the association decided to act after receiving several low bids, including some of up to 20 per cent lower than the average. He said: ‘We feel that without a clause in the contract we could be subject to contractors making a challenge.’

The move follows concern in the sector about ‘suicide-bidding’, in which companies bid at amounts that do not cover the cost of their work. This can lead to poor quality service and to firms seeking contract loopholes to charge clients extra.

Suicide-bidding was partly blamed for last year’s collapse of contractors Connaught and Rok.

Peter Kitson, solicitor at Trowers & Hamlins, confirmed a small number of associations are now using the clauses. Mr Kitson warned that any clause would have to comply with EU procurement regulations, which aim to ensure value for money.

The move was welcomed by contractors, including United House, Willmott Dixon, Lovell and Morrison. Stewart Davenport, managing director of Lovell, said: ‘This is the right thing to do. If bids come in too low contractors might start looking at every claim possible and it is not possible to have a proper relationship.’

Readers' comments (7)

  • Alpha One

    Seems sensible to me.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Wouldn't confirming the supplier's ability to do the work form part of the due diligence on any sizeable service contract?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Rick Campbell

    Oh dear, I find myself in agreement with Alpha One, AGAIN!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Progressive Solutions Required

    From the headline I thought this was going to be the regular Friday outing from Shapps - his new choice based letting scheme where the succesful bidder - well you get the picture, and it would help him keep his promise to end homelessness.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • The Democratic Dictator

    First suicide bombing, now suicide bidding....what are they going to outlaw next?

    In my country, if you get £100 worth of work done for £1, it is considered a poor deal - after all, what are slaves for !!!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • So the Willmott Dixon bid for Notting Hill Housing Trust's maintenance contract isn't suicide? I guess as WD can afford a loss leader it's ok. So what about staff and subbies... Lovely.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • isn't this the old scam where the contractor submits the lowest bid in order to win contract and then subsequently bumps up the price while laughing all the way to the bank?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say

You must sign in to make a comment

sign in register

Newsletter Sign-up

More Newsletters



  • Contractors for £1 billion housing framework selected

    23 October 2013

    Thirty three contractors from across the UK have been selected for a £1 billion housing framework.

  • KPMG appointed in NBS repricing battle


    Landlords locked in a legal wrangle with Newcastle Building Society over the threat of loan repricing have appointed accountants to bolster their case.

  • Investor confirms housing association PRS deal

    28 June 2013

    Investor M&G has finalised a deal with housing association Poplar Harca and contractor Willmott Dixon to fund the development of 233 homes in Tower Hamlets, east London.

  • Breaking free to build homes


    Tearing loose from housing revenue accounts, councils are setting up their own companies to provide homes. Pete Apps finds out who is escaping

  • Top 50 affordable developments revealed


    For the second year running, Inside Housing’s panel of judges have applied their strict criteria to a huge number of competition entries to pin down the very best affordable housing schemes in the UK.


  • Crystal clear


    Landlords must ensure their tenders are unambiguous if they are to avoid challenges from suppliers, says Andrew Millross

  • Energy efficient

    10 May 2013

    Landlords should carefully consider energy efficient offers that are likely to come their way, says Patrick Sweeney

  • The price is right


    Legal reforms should reduce the cost of going to court, says Anna-Liisa Blanks-Walden, senior associate at Clarke Willmott

  • Keeping tenants safe


    Landlords should be aware of changes to the definition of domestic violence, says Paul Hayes, head of housing litigation and dispute resolution at Lewis Silkin

  • Breaking point


    Social landlords with diverse property portfolios need to be aware of complications relating to commercial leases, says Neil Ham