Monday, 20 October 2014

Floating voters

US special logo

American elections are complex affairs, but the heart of a campaign is data: who are your voters? Where do they live? How do you contact them? And so forth. This puts the US housing crash and resulting foreclosure crisis that helped lay low the global economy in a very political light.

In August, canvassers in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, tasked with contacting some of the strongest supporters of Barack Obama - black voters - found more than 60 per cent of the names on their list were confirmed as no longer at their address. Through foreclosure or abandonment, this demographic block had melted away. There is now an unspoken fear among political operatives tasked with finding, contacting, and getting voters to the polls that this task will prove difficult.

In 2010, in an election to replace Massachusetts senator Ted Kennedy, Republican Scott Brown shocked the country by winning in a Democratic leaning state. Political scientists Tom Ferguson and Jie Chen traced this upset to job losses and the housing crash: for every 1 per cent decline in housing values, the Democratic share of the vote fell by a fifth of a per cent.

Sure enough, later that year, the Republicans swept the Democrats in legislative elections, electoral revenge for $3.1 to $4.4 trillion of home equity being wiped from the balance sheet of the American middle class. Since then, the economy has stabilised into a slow growth pattern, with housing values - still backed by the government’s backstopping of the mortgage market - ending their slide.

What is most surprising about the foreclosure crisis is how little attention it’s getting on an electoral level. Six years into the epidemic of foreclosures, there is still no public database of the problem.

The reason the housing crash is absent from the political debate is because both major party candidates largely agree on what to do. Republican Mitt Romney has said he wants to see foreclosures continue until the housing market hits bottom, and Mr Obama’s housing programmes are designed to spread out foreclosures, so American banks won’t have to take balance sheet hits all at once. Both believe that a mandatory programme to restructure mortgages is unworkable.

Some 10 million homes are on the road to foreclosure, according to Amherst Securities analyst Laurie Goodman. Where will all this property go? One of the hottest investment sectors is converting foreclosures to rentals, with the first sales of properties happening a few weeks ago. The US, which has based its core political ideology since the 1930s on homeownership as a mechanism for delivering prosperity, is returning to a society of landlords and tenants.

It’s not clear how this will affect elections going forward, or the mortgage market. One thing is for sure - the US is a very different country than it was just six years ago.

Matt Stoller is a fellow at the Roosevelt Institute

Have your say

You must sign in to make a comment

sign in register

Newsletter Sign-up

More Newsletters



  • Retaliatory evictions bill gets government backing

    11 September 2014

    The government has today backed a private members bill seeking to outlaw retaliatory evictions.

  • Free exchange

    11 December 2013

  • All in his Stride


    Incoming Chartered Institute of Housing president Steve Stride has uncompromising views and big ambitions for what social landlords can achieve. Nick Duxbury joins the Poplar Harca chief executive on a tour of the borough to hear his plans

  • Jousting over housing


    With campaign season fast approaching, would-be councillors are taking a stab at the housing crisis to win votes. Caroline Thorpe discovers their battle plans

  • If the hat fits: John Healey's housing mission

    11 September 2014

    Former Labour housing minister John Healey is on a mission to put housing at the top of the electoral agenda - and don his hard hat and reprise a cabinet housing role. Nick Duxbury meets him


  • Connect found


    A mobile phone health and well-being ‘app’ is transforming the lives of Bristol residents. Alex Turner reports

  • Downsizing with the bedroom tax

    17 July 2014

    The price for underoccupying a home is high for many vulnerable people. Jess McCabe visits Stoke-on-Trent to find out how landlords are attempting to help

  • Dragons' Den for retrofit technology

    4 September 2014

    Copying the popular BBC format, Accord Group set up a Dragons’ Den of its own to find the best green technologies to test in a £3m retrofit project. Simon Brandon finds out why

  • Trade secrets


    Can learning from other sectors help social landlords do their jobs better? Heather Spurr visits retail icon John Lewis with a number of landlords to find out

IH Subscription