Wednesday, 22 October 2014

Steps to success

Senior housing figures are about to gather in London for the National Housing Federation’s annual leaders’ forum. They do so at a time when a number of high-profile members of the sector have argued that providers face greater risks as business models become more complex and that non-executive boards need to raise their game to understand, manage and overcome these risks.

There is no doubt that housing and care organisations have become much bigger and more complex than they were when I started my career in the 1970s. It is also true that the external environment is very different. Changes to revenue and capital funding and to loan finance have led to the need to innovate and transform housing organisations to ensure that they survive and prosper in increasingly difficult circumstances. An old friend likened the new world to dancing on a flying carpet.

What has not changed is the growing demand for the housing care and community services that we provide. The very same factors that have brought about the need to change our financial and business models have ensured that the demand for our services increase at the same time as our ability to provide more is threatened by the effects of the recession and government policies. To put it simply we are expected to do more for less in an extremely volatile climate.

So, is it correct to place the emphasis on boards to ensure that associations do not go under and can continue to innovate? Of course boards have an important role to play in this but what is really needed in this new era is excellent leadership at executive and non-executive level: Leadership that scans the horizon and puts in place strategies to address the new challenges and minimise the risks: Leadership that is clear where it wants to go and how it is going to get there: Leadership that innovates to find new ways of doing things. Leadership that works with its colleagues, residents and customers to ensure their needs are understood and incorporated in business plans: Leadership that works in partnership with all stakeholders: Leadership that is comfortable with the unknown: Leadership that inspires others: Leadership that leaves its ego by the door. And above all leadership that remembers the values of an organisation and why it exists.

In my view the last point is the most important of all and one that I fear is becoming lost in the debate about the challenges we face.  Of course our current leaders require a greater understanding of financial risk and a higher level of business acumen than they did in the past when the world was much simpler. Organisations have become more commercial. The operational and financial successes of recent years appear to show that many are able to adapt successfully to face new challenges. Even in the current climate for every one Cosmopolitan there are many successful organisations. This success and the ability to continue to be successful in the future will mean nothing if our purpose is forgotten. What should differentiate us from private sector in this race to become more commercial is the social purpose of our work. Return on capital invested should be measured as much in social terms as in financial. Leaders should not just be stress testing financial and other risks of new projects they should be asking the question how does this help us to further our values and can we measure that as well. This is the way in which we will know that we are still adhering to the original values of an organisation. If this is missing from the board challenge, if this is not part of the leader’s armoury then we will have failed. The sector at its best is a great example of blending business acumen with social values. The leaders that achieve this are the ones that remember that they are mere stewards, who for a short period of time have the privilege of leading organisations which have a past as well as a future. Their job is to secure the future while remembering the past. It is not just boards that have this responsibility it is the job of everyone who aspires to leadership in this sector.

In a recent discussion with a very senior civil servant I was asked why the government should not just transfer all social housing to the private sector. Apart from pointing out that this would be difficult to do in legal terms I reminded him that the social value of our work would be lost and that in many cases this work helped to transform lives and hold communities together. He only really began to take notice when I added that this work directly helped the economy and saved the exchequer millions of pounds. Staying true to our values not only saves lives it also saves money and may prevent Cosmopolitan type failures in the future.

Tom Murtha is former chief executive of Midland Heart

Readers' comments (3)

  • Tenantplustwo

    Whom build these homes it taxpayers money and its taxpayers money that keeps these Housing/Council Social Housing the flow of money going into these Housing Association. Liken the Taxpayers paid for all these Shared Ownership Problems and the Grant

    For pity sake they be charging what they want to charge. Look at all others the GOVERNMENT SOLD

    Look at the Service Charges

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Tenantplustwo

    STOP THE beginning of the privatisation of social housing

    More recently, the UK High Court in Weaver v. London and Quadrant Housing Trust [2008] has ruled that housing associations were public authorities and as a result could be subject to judicial review in certain circumstances.[2] The court stated that the housing association sector was 'permeated by state control and influence with a view to meeting the Government's aims for affordable housing, and in which RSLs work side by side with, and can in a very real sense be said to take the place of, local authorities'.
    This issue has wider political significance since housing associations borrowing (which stood at approximately £30 billion in 2006)[3] does not currently contribute to the UK's public sector borrowing requirement, the control of which is both a stated government objective and part of the EU's criteria for membership of the European single currency.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • This is a timely reminder of the reasons for social housing, since it is no surprise that ‘ethos’ no longer occupies a central position in the cultural consciousness of the leadership today, as it would have done for activists during its early history; for it is no different when clergy lose sight of their spiritual calling and develop a zeal for chasing what is in the offertory plate.

    Should a fly on the wall be asked of the latest at the NHF event, it is certain that many a chief executive would be heard to name financial strength as their raison d’être. This isn’t actually so bad compared to some who just compete to be the largest beast of them all! Rarely do tenants and communities feature in pronouncements, except to mention what financial burden they’ve become.

    Of course housing associations should be well run financial organisations, but they should not become financial institutions. Why? See how the banks brought us to our knees and how long recovery is taking! But that’s a different story.

    Regrettably, the era of leadership to whom social value was the reason for striving - who remember why their organisations exist - is gone, with the remorseless quest of many landlords to be just ‘bigger! For as long as the asymmetrical imbalance of power between the behemoth social landlords and individual tenants continues to get wider the less consideration of ethos and values there will be.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say

You must sign in to make a comment

sign in register

Newsletter Sign-up

More Newsletters



  • Cosmopolitan: the true story


    The financial crisis which hit Cosmopolitan in 2012 and brought the housing association to its knees changed the social housing sector forever. Carl Brown reveals for the first time exactly how it happened and the lessons learned

  • Using their religion


    The church is right to speak out - welfare reform is exposing too many people to poverty, says Ann O’Byrne

  • Running commentary from Inside Housing's editors


    They have more than 60 years’ experience in housing journalism between them - but what do they really think about the sector? Nick Duxbury gathered Inside Housing editors past and present to find out

  • What’s in a name?


    The government has announced plans for a series of new garden cities. Simon Brandon checks out one of the originals and asks if the new breed will live up to founding father Ebenezer Howard’s vision

  • Agent for change


    The first 100 days in the job are any new executive’s most crucial. So how does Dame Clare Tickell plan to make her mark at Hanover? Lydia Stockdale finds out


  • Expert opinion


    Board members need to keep the idea of public service uppermost in their minds, writes Julie Fadden

  • Connect found


    A mobile phone health and well-being ‘app’ is transforming the lives of Bristol residents. Alex Turner reports

  • Back on the front line


    WM Housing chief executive Pat Brandum went back to the shop floor to experience first-hand how her organisation helps vulnerable young people. Alex Turner finds out what she learned

  • Room for procurement savings


    Scotland’s social housing sector is still dogged by the spectre of unnecessary procurement costs but it could save up to £42 million per year

  • Sowing the seeds


    Sanctuary Housing is collaborating with charity Fixers to inspire young people to tackle issues they feel strongly about in their community. Austin Macauley reports

IH Subscription



You will soon need to sign into using your email address rather than your username.

If you are unsure which email address is linked to your account, please Click Here. Your password will remain the same.

If you have a print subscription we need to ensure that we have the correct details in order to link your subscription to your online account, for more information Click Here.

Click here to close window