Thursday, 24 April 2014

Why governance style matters

The governance crisis at Places for People Group could have happened to any number of other social landlords, the group's chair has told Inside Housing.

The governance crisis at Places for People Group could have happened to any number of other social landlords, the group's chair has told Inside Housing.Speaking following the Housing Corporation's decision to remove PfP from supervision (Inside Housing, 23 July), Zenna Atkins says similar difficulties could still occur elsewhere. The rapid growth experienced by many housing associations over recent years means governance procedures have not always kept pace.PfP's difficulties hit the headlines in September 2003 when five board members were facing expulsion following a row over the relationship between then chair Sebert Cox and chief executive David Cowans. At the time, Inside Housing reported the split focused on a transfer deal and a pay rise handed to Mr Cowans.Today, Ms Atkins is keen to focus on the changes that have taken place since then. And, while PfP may be the most high-profile case, she does not believe it is unique.She says: ‘The organisation had grown up and grown enormously and some of the governance pressures and governance styles hadn't accelerated at the same speed.'I actually believe it happens in most fast-growing organisations in the public sector. Fortunately for other associations they have been able to look and learn. Hopefully, they won't have to go through what we went through.'The issues at PfP, she says, ‘centred around a high-level board disagreement and that disagreement, as I understand it, really focused on styles'.She adds: ‘Because it broke very publicly the Housing Corporation were left with very little option but to come in with the full weight of the sanctions that they hold.'That meant some serious soul searching at PfP, which faced an unprecedented level of scrutiny. Consultants from the Office for Public Management and Institute of Directors were also involved.The corporation's sanctions formally came to an end last week, when the corporation removed PfP from supervision. The change in status means PfP now has shadow partnering status.While not immediately able to join the corporation's list of 71 partnering associations, PfP will get the chance to pick up the baton if any of the 71 slip up or find they have overcommitted themselves.Not gaining partnering status immediately is no surprise to Ms Atkins.‘I wouldn't expect them to change the rules simply because we are out of supervision,' she says. But she adds that it is simply a question of time.‘My feeling is the Housing Corporation would want the big players in there. I think it's unlikely someone will trip up. I think what will happen is that some of the organisations will realise they have overcommitted.'Ms Atkins also plays down the effect that it has had on the organisation, which still managed to come second in the league of top housing association developers earlier this year.She is keen to stress that PfP remains pioneering. The organisation is developing an arm called Renovate, which aims to develop the skills needed by the group.It also has a partnership with Training for Life, which runs projects to provide work and training opportunities.So will PfP be back at the top of the development table next year? Ms Atkins claims it doesn't matter and that what counts is that PfP is able to create sustainable communities in places where people want to live.She says: ‘For me none of this is about building the size of the organisation.'And the difficulties have had their positive side. ‘Although this has been bloody painful it's also been a fantastic learning opportunity.‘In some ways Places for People has done the sector a great service.'

Related

Articles

  • PfP buys flats for £77m

    26 July 2013

    Places for People has bought 654 flats across England from developer Urban Splash for £77 million.

  • Joint venture for social landlord and developer

    26 September 2013

    A housing association is set to create a joint venture with a developer, after the housing association recently bought 654 flats across England from the developer for £77 million.

  • Red face

    6 December 2013

  • Friendly face

    12/07/2013

    Andy Atkins is the environmental campaigner who gets results. The Friends of the Earth chief tells Jess McCabe how his journey from dodging dictators in Chile to rescuing bees has convinced him that housing can save the planet

  • PfP to sell heating systems to schools and hospitals

    26 June 2013

    Places for People is planning to sell communal heating systems to schools and hospitals through a joint venture. 

Resources

  • Acting out to tackle domestic abuse

    28/03/2014

    An interactive training course is helping housing professionals in the south west identify and tackle domestic abuse. Lydia Stockdale finds out how

  • You are where you live

    21/06/2013

    Stunning views and elegant Georgian architecture aren’t necessarily what you would expect from a homelessness hostel. Caroline Thorpe investigates why one charity thinks a beautiful location is key to its success

  • Back on the front line

    15/11/2013

    WM Housing chief executive Pat Brandum went back to the shop floor to experience first-hand how her organisation helps vulnerable young people. Alex Turner finds out what she learned

  • Global reach

    09/08/2013

    Off on holiday this summer? Perhaps you’d prefer to spend a longer stint abroad? Here, Caroline Thorpe speaks to housing professionals based overseas about how their UK experience has gone down among employers on the other side of the world

  • The long road to justice

    09/08/2013

    The High Court’s decision regarding the bedroom tax and disabled people is just the beginning, says Jane Plant, an associate at Weightmans