Friday, 18 April 2014

Bedroom tax faces second legal challenge

Human rights group Liberty is launching legal action against the government’s penalty for under-occupation of social housing.

The organisation said it will seek a judicial review as it believes the penalty, widely known as the ‘bedroom tax’, breaches the European Convention on Human Rights. Liberty said it will argue that the policy is discriminatory and would infringe on family life.

Under the penalty, which comes in from 1 April, working age social tenants on housing benefit will have their payments cut if they are deemed to have one or more spare bedrooms under the government’s size criteria.

Corinna Ferguson, legal officer for Liberty, said:  ‘Why is a government that prides itself on prioritising families penalising people merely for having children?’

Liberty is representing three people whose families are affected by the changes:

  • Simon Cohen, from Gloucestershire, whose 12-year-old son lives with him four days a week in his two-bedroom house. Under the scheme his son will not be considered part of his household – his room will therefore be deemed ‘unoccupied’.
  • Mark Hutchinson, from Derbyshire, whose seven-year-old daughter and eight-year-old stepson reside with him at weekends and during school holidays.
  • Kim Cotton, from Hampshire, whose eleven-year-old daughter and eight-year-old son live with her every other week.

Ms Ferguson said that the penalty threatened  thousands of shared care arrangements for children. ‘In no way can these loving parents be accused of “under-occupying” their properties or having “spare bedrooms” – these rooms are very much their children’s and home to many of their belongings.’

Earlier this month a separate challenge to the penalty was brought on behalf of 10 vulnerable and disabled children who will be affected by the policy. The High Court is expected to rule on whether this challenge can proceed within the next few days.

Newsletter Sign-up

More Newsletters



  • High Court to rule on bedroom tax case

    30 July 2013

    The High Court is expected to rule on a legal challenge to the bedroom tax today, which was brought by 10 families with vulnerable and disabled children.

  • Court asked to rule against bedroom tax

    15 May 2013

    The High Court was asked today to declare that the government’s so-called ‘bedroom tax’ unlawfully discriminates against disabled people in social housing.

  • Successful human rights appeal against bedroom tax

    19 February 2014

    A tribunal has found imposing the bedroom tax on a father who said he needed a second room to accommodate his teenage daughter when she stays with him was an infringement of his human rights.

  • Funding for homes to beat 'bedroom tax'

    8 May 2013

    The Welsh Government has provided £20 million to build smaller homes to reduce the number of people hit by a penalty for under-occupation of social housing.

  • Rape victim legally challenges bedroom tax

    28 May 2013

    A victim of rape, assault, harassment and stalking has launched a legal challenge against the bedroom tax on the grounds it is ‘discriminatory’.


  • The Matchmakers


    Do you have tenants who can’t pay their rent because of welfare reform? Well, speed dating might provide an unlikely solution to your problems, as Alex Turner reports

  • The long road to justice


    The High Court’s decision regarding the bedroom tax and disabled people is just the beginning, says Jane Plant, an associate at Weightmans

  • Home help


    Welfare reform has piled financial pressure on tenants and their landlords alike. Alex Turner meets a former housing professional who quit her job to start a business she hopes will reduce rent arrears and improve residents’ lives

  • Rights law is an asset


    Without article 8, those in bedroom tax disputes will have an uphill struggle, says Giles Peaker, solicitor at Anthony Gold

  • Make yourself at home


    A midlands-based landlord is offering tenants a chance to get a foot on the housing ladder and acquire work skills by building their own homes, as Helen Clifton finds out