Wednesday, 26 October 2016

DWP faces legal challenge over benefit cap

Four families have launched a legal challenge against the government’s benefit cap on the grounds it is ‘discriminatory and unreasonable’.

The families have issued judicial review proceedings against the work and pensions secretary Iain Duncan Smith today at London’s High Court.

Under the policy, which has been applied since 15 April in four boroughs including Haringey where one of the families lives, the government has capped total household benefits at £500 a week for couples and lone parents, and £350 a week for single adults.

The government plans to roll the cap out across the rest of the country from 15 July.

The eight claimants – one parent and one child from each family – will challenge Part 8A of the Housing Benefit Regulations 2006 which was inserted as part of the welfare reform act last year.

They will argue that the regulations are discriminatory and unreasonable. In addition, they will argue that the secretary of state did not take into account the impact of the policy on women, children, the disabled, racial and religious minorities, and carers when formulating the policy.

Hopkin Murray Beskine, the law firm representing the families, said that two of the families are expected to immediately fall into rent arrears and face eviction and street homelessness.

This is because their rent exceeds £500 a week.

HMB added that two of the families have fled domestic violence in circumstances where they were financially reliant upon their abusive partners and now risk losing their homes.

The families have not been named because two of the women are at risk of violence from their ex-husbands.

The claims are supported by charity Women’s Aid which has submitted witness evidence.

Rebekah Carrier, solicitor at HMB said: ‘This is a cruel and misguided policy.  It will have a catastrophic impact on our clients and many thousands more vulnerable children and adults.  They face street homelessness and starvation. 

‘A year ago the Children’s Commissioner warned the government that these changes would result in a sharp increase in child poverty and homelessness, with a disproportionate impact upon disabled children and children of disabled parents, and some BME groups. The difficulties now faced by my clients were predictable and avoidable.’

A Department for Work and Pensions spokesperson said: ‘We are confident that the benefit cap measures are lawful and they do not discriminate against any groups.

‘The benefit cap sets a fair limit to what people can expect to get from the welfare system - so that claimants cannot receive more than £500 a week, the average household income.’

Readers' comments (20)

Comments are only open to subscribers of Inside Housing

Already a subscriber?

If you’re already a subscriber to Inside Housing, your subscription may not be linked to your online account. You can link your subscription from within the My Account section of the website and clicking on Link My Account.

Not yet a subscriber?

If you don't yet subscribe to Inside Housing, please visit our subscription page to view our various subscription packages.

Have your say

You must sign in to make a comment

sign in register

Newsletter Sign-up



  • DWP: Figures show benefit cap is working

    5 August 2016

    More than 23,000 people have moved off the benefit cap and into work since its introduction in 2013, according to the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP).

  • Freud faces criticism for lack of 'LHA cap' clarity

    29 June 2016

    The welfare reform minister faced criticism for failing to provide details of the government’s plan for funding supported housing, despite recommendations from the sector to solve the impasse.

  • New minister faces call to re-think 'LHA cap'

    21 March 2016

    New work and pensions secretary Stephen Crabb is facing immediate calls to re-examine plans to apply a new housing benefit cap to supported housing.

  • Carers to be exempt from benefit cap

    26 January 2016

    Carers will be exempt from the £26,000 a year cap on benefits, the government has announced.

  • DWP letter follows benefit cap ruling

    27 November 2015

    The Department for Work and Pensions has issued an urgent letter to councils after the High Court ruled the existing £26,000-a-year household benefit cap unlawfully discriminates against disabed people.

IH Subscription