Saturday, 04 February 2012

History of violence

A Court of Appeal ruling means landlords can seek possession on grounds of domestic violence even after the victim has fled, says Ian Larkins

Djilali Hadjzi was a tenant of Metropolitan Housing Trust and had a history of physical violence and threats towards his family. In 2006, he left his wife and moved from the property but the violence continued and in 2007, Mr Hadjzi’s wife and children moved out. Mr Hadjzi then moved back into the property.

Metropolitan sought possession of the property on various grounds, including ground 14A of the Housing Act 1988 relating to domestic violence. The first instance judge held ground 14A only applied while the tenant and his wife were living in the property as a couple so would not apply in this case as the violence and threats occurred after they had ceased to live together.

Metropolitan appealed this decision and the Court of Appeal considered there was nothing ambiguous about ground 14A. It did not expressly state or imply that the parties to the relationship had to live together as a couple at the date of the causative violence or the relevant triggering event.
The court said: ‘Why should the timing of departure from the property by the victim of the violence make any difference to the availability of that ground of possession to the landlord?’

The court continued by expressing great concern over the idea that a perpetrator of physical violence could obtain statutory protection simply because the violence forced a victim to flee only after that perpetrator had left. Accordingly, the first instance judge’s refusal to grant a possession order was wrong and the matter has been remitted for reconsideration in light of this.

Ian Larkins is a solicitor in the social housing team at Weightmans
Ian.larkins@weightmans.com

Have your say

You must sign in to make a comment

sign in register

Related

Articles

Resources

  • Exit strategy

    03/02/2012

    Tenants are wholly responsible for exercising break clauses, says Matthew Lake

  • Counting the costs

    11/11/2011

    Just because you are successful at trial doesn’t mean you will recover all your legal costs, says Dan Butler

  • A quick solution

    25/11/2011

    A recent case shows landlords should not have to go through a long process when seeking possession, says Ruth Hills

  • Turning down trouble

    04/02/2011

    A mandatory ground for possession in cases of anti-social behaviour is unworkable, says barrister Jon Mack

  • What’s in the post?

    18/11/2011

    Landlords’ administrative errors can lead to time-consuming court cases, says Jane Plant, associate at Weightmans

Latest Jobs

  • Growth & Partnerships Development Manager

    Equity Housing is a fast growing Housing Association who have undertaken a strong development plan across the North West region. ...

    Competitive

    Closing: 2012-02-17 00:00:00

  • Local Income Officer

    We are currently seeking a Local Income Officer to be responsible for providing a comprehensive legal service by representing MHP ...

    £20000 - £29999 annum

  • Maintenance Services Manager

    Heritage Care is a charitable care and support provider, with an enviable reputation as an employer that values, supports and ...

    £31,349 p.a. pro rata

    Closing: 2012-02-17 00:00:00

  • Anti-social Behaviour Officer

    As part of our hard working and dedicated team, you’ll play a key role in ensuring our tenants feel safe ...

    £22,283 - £28,590 + 10% car allowance

    Closing: 2012-02-18 00:00:00

  • Head of Design and Procurement

    £50,425 pa

    Closing: 2012-02-21 00:00:00