Saturday, 04 February 2012

Union reports complaints against association chief executive to regulator

Cestria probes staff grievances

Staff at a north east housing association have contacted the housing regulator about alleged bullying at the organisation.

Trade union the GMB submitted several statements from staff at 4,300-home Cestria Community Housing, based in Chester-le-Street to the Tenant Services Authority alleging they were bullied or witnessed bullying by the organisation’s chief executive, Ian Broughton.

The organisation’s board has commissioned an investigation, understood to be being carried out by a firm of solicitors, to examine complaints by staff.

The TSA said it will agree the scope and terms of the investigation.

Stephen Thompkins, regional organiser for GMB, said the union thought the chief executive should be suspended during the investigation.

‘We are disappointed that this has not happened but we have no choice but to let the investigation take its course and hope it will get to the bottom of what has been going on,’ he said.

A spokesperson for the TSA said the regulator has no ‘statutory remit’ to intervene in individual employment matters. She said: ‘We are aware of the complaints that have been made and will agree the scope and terms of the independent investigation that is being commissioned by Cestria’s board.’

Paul Tinnion, chair of Cestria Community Housing’s, said Mr Broughton and his team had been doing a ‘very good job during a difficult time of change at the organisation’.

He said: ‘Like any transfer organisation we have had to adapt to new ways of working in order to deliver a first class service to our tenants. As a consequence we are investigating a number of complaints made by some members of staff.’

Mr Tinnion confirmed that the TSA had been in contact with Cestria’s board and said it was ‘content with the action we are taking’. He added: ‘There is no reason to suspend anyone in relation to these matters.’

Mr Broughton declined to comment.

Readers' comments (51)

  • like other poorly performing organisations - Cestria have to deal with staff who dont like being told to change. It was a joke the service that used to be provided by these people - get a good loook at yourselves and start to earn your wages. Dont be defensive get real!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • The author of the first comment either doesn't know what he/she is talking about or is actually Ian Broughton. The staff at Cestria generally are extremely dedicated and hard working, professional people who have to deal with a dictatorial style from senior management/exec team. I expect more details to come out over the coming weeks.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I would not be surprised if findings prove this to be yet another example of bullies and manipulators running housing associations

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Kass - do you have previous 'examples' as you quote, or are you spewing your usual hatred of everything housing related?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Kass is correct in this instance, and it extends to ALMOs too.
    For once I will use the anon button as I still am in fear of retribution.

    Outsiders may not be aware but a swift way to stop being able to work in this sector is to complain about management bullying.

    I have been directly bullied in both an RSL and an ALMO.

    In the case of the latter, several other staff have chosen to move on as a result of the bullying executive (who is also a RSL Board Member). Complaints have resulted in persecution of the staff rather than action against the bully.

    In the case of the RSL the bullying Director actually headed the investigative panel that ended up advising for the dismissal of the staff member.

    Colleagues have experienced bullying at their previous workplaces too, making clearly not an isolated activity.

    There is no excuse for the behaviour of senior staff. It is true though that pressures to reduce costs, increase performance, avoid takeover and merger etc must all play their part.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • The bullies are there and real. The thrive on fear and despair, making lives a living hell. Sadly, from experience, Kass is correct to assume senior placed bullies within housing.
    IH could do a service a dig into this, but it is impossible to complain against senior staff in this sector and still work in it.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • There have been staff suspended from Cestria for far less, and some even dismissed. Does this mean that Mr Broughton et al are exempt from the rules which apply to everyone else? Perhaps, given his defence of the man and the situation and the fact he obviously considers suspension unnecessary, perhaps the Chair should now consider his own position?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Commenting on the first anonymous post. How do you know how other organisations are performing, the characteristics of cestria's staff and the standard of service they supplied before transfer? For all we know you could be a disgruntled tenant or a former employee who could'nt cope with the mental or physical strains that may come working for such an organisation! Obviously these allegations have some substance or SEVERAL would not have been submitted! My suprise comes with the boards decision not to suspend the accused which in my opinion shows they either have no backbone or are afraid of the accused! From my experiance, suspension is inevitable whilst an investigation is ongoing!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • The investigation will no doubt be a whitewash. Events have demonstrated a certain amount of collusion with the board/chief exec.
    This would suggest that there needs to be a truly independant investigation, I doubt the TSA are up to the job though.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • When performance dips there is usually a reason. Surely the whole organisation can't be resistant to change? Speaking out against bullies takes an incredible amount of courage, especially when the bullying comes from the very top of the organisation as is alleged here. I hope the investigation is thorough and impartial and the outcome offers some reassurance to those involved.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

View results 10 per page | 20 per page | 50 per page |

Have your say

You must sign in to make a comment

sign in register

Related

Articles

  • Council hit by corruption claims

    21 September 2011

    A council repairs department is under investigation by police and an auditing firm following allegations of corruption.

  • Rosie Banks

    27 September 2011

    Cestria Community Housing, which owns and manages 4,300 properties in Chester-le-Street, has welcomed a new member of staff to its management team.

  • MPs fear 'another Southern Cross'

    6 December 2011

    The government is not doing enough to monitor the finances of England’s care homes, a House of Commons committee has said.

  • Care home staff suspended amid abuse allegations

    10 January 2012

    A care home has suspended four members of staff after an investigation was launched into allegations of physical and verbal abuse of a dementia sufferer.

  • United front

    12/08/2011

    Local authorities must recognise that homelessness is an issue for the whole council if they are to avoid complaints

Resources

  • Get some expert advice

    10/06/2011

    Every week Inside Housing’s Need to Know section brings you best practice advice and information on the subjects most concerning you. Free with today’s magazine is the first ever Need to Know supplement. Here our Ask the Experts panel answer some of the key questions it raises

  • Strictly boardroom

    04/02/2011

    New research reveals housing’s boardrooms are divided, as executives and their boards fail to see eye to eye. Caroline Thorpe analyses the results of Inside Housing’s inaugural governance survey and asks how serious the split is at a time when sloppy scrutiny is simply not an option.

  • Some food for thought

    01/07/2011

    Landlords should assess their level of risk as the Bribery Act comes into force, says Kirsty Thompson, solicitor at Devonshires

  • Weather any storms

    02/09/2011

    New guidelines will help landlords comply with the Human Rights Act, says Nnenna Morah, senior associate in the social housing team at Lewis Silkin

  • A quick solution

    25/11/2011

    A recent case shows landlords should not have to go through a long process when seeking possession, says Ruth Hills

Latest Jobs

  • Head of Strategy & Governance

    We are at an exciting point in our journey to create a great company that delivers the best services – ...

    £65,000

    Closing: 2012-02-24 00:00:00

  • Board Members

    We are seeking to recruit professional board members with expertise in financa, legal or human resources for a small dynamic ...

    Expenses

    Closing: 2012-03-07 00:00:00

  • Non-Executive Director

    Expenses

    Closing: 2012-02-20 00:00:00

  • Independent Board Member

    Trafford Housing Trust provide over 9,000 homes in Trafford, Greater Manchester - including homes to rent, homes for shared ownership, ...

    £4,000 per annum

    Closing: 2012-02-27 00:00:00

  • Board Member

    Accent Group is a successful national organisation, with a strong commitment to its customers, and to making a real difference ...

    £8K Per Annum

    Closing: 2012-02-17 00:00:00