Tuesday, 23 May 2017

Data shows four London boroughs where scheme won’t work

Major flaws revealed in pay-to-stay policy

The government’s pay-to-stay policy will not work in parts of 16 local authority areas across London because tenants will have to earn more than the £60,000 cap to be able to pay affordable rents.

Under pay-to-stay proposals outlined last month, social landlords will be able to force tenants who have a household income of more than £60,000 a year to pay full market rent or move into the private rented sector.

However, exclusive data from consultancy Hometrack reveals that in four boroughs this will not be possible for tenants paying affordable rents.

This is because tenants would need an income of up to £82,226 to pay the rent even if it is set at 63 per cent of the market rate - the average proportion charged under the scheme - rather than the 80 per cent maximum allowed.

The research, labelled ‘horrifying’ by one landlord, also lays bare the extent to which the affordable rent product is unaffordable for many social tenants.

Hometrack also found there were 88 wards across 16 boroughs with a total of 131,000 social homes that could only be afforded by households earning more than £60,000 a year - if rents were set at 63 per cent of the market rate.

Although these homes will mostly be for social rent, landlords are increasingly converting re-lets to affordable rent.

Housing minister Mark Prisk has said that landlords taking part in the next £2.8 billion round of affordable rent will be expected to consider all re-lets for conversions.

In Kensington and Chelsea, which is the most expensive borough, the research suggests that a household would need to earn £82,226 a year to be able to pay affordable rent.

Similarly, in Westminster, households would need to earn £82,197. In City of London households would need to earn £68,609, and in Camden, households would need an income of £66,405.

Julian Fulbrook, cabinet member for housing at Camden Council, described the research as ‘horrifying’ and said the authority would not be implementing pay-to-stay.

‘These are staggering figures, and back up our own research. This [pay-to-stay] is not something we want to spend time and effort on,’ he added.

Westminster Council said it supports the principle of the [pay-to-stay] policy but may increase the £60,000 cap.

Brendan Sarsfield, chief executive of Family Mosaic and leader of the G15 group of the largest developing London associations said: ‘These figures show that the affordable rent regime is not working. Affordable rent is an intermediate product, not a social housing product.’

Richard Donnell, director at Hometrack, explained: ‘We took [median] rental values for two-bed homes across all wards in London. We took 63 per cent of open market rental value as the affordable rent and assumed 35 per cent of net income was spent on housing costs. Using these assumptions… we then weighted the analysis to where social rented stock is most prevalent [in each ward].’

Top 10 income requirements

London boroughIncome needed to pay affordable rent
Kensington and Chelsea£82,226
City of Westminster£82,197
City of London£68,609
Hammersmith & Fulham£53,766
Tower Hamlets£51,869

Readers' comments (34)

Comments are only open to subscribers of Inside Housing

Already a subscriber?

If you’re already a subscriber to Inside Housing, your subscription may not be linked to your online account. You can link your subscription from within the My Account section of the website and clicking on Link My Account.

Not yet a subscriber?

If you don't yet subscribe to Inside Housing, please visit our subscription page to view our various subscription packages.

Have your say

You must sign in to make a comment

sign in register


Newsletter Sign-up



  • Councils reject voluntary Pay to Stay

    24 November 2016

    Conservative councils are among several which will not introduce the controversial Pay to Stay policy for their tenants following the government’s decision to make it voluntary.

  • Government scraps compulsory Pay to Stay

    21 November 2016

    The government has scrapped its plans to force councils to charge higher-income tenants rents of up to market rates.

  • Ministers consider Pay to Stay exemption

    5 October 2016

    The Department for Communities and Local Government (DCLG) will consider exempting council tenants from Pay to Stay in areas where social rents and market rents are similar.

  • Government urged to delay Pay to Stay

    27 July 2016

    Councils and arm’s-length management organisations are calling on ministers to delay the introduction of Pay to Stay to avoid a ‘tight’ timetable, after the government failed to publish regulations before the parliamentary recess.

  • Councils sound warning over Pay to Stay timetable

    24 June 2016

    The government is facing pressure from councils over the “horrendously short” timescale required to implement its controversial Pay to Stay policy by April next year.

IH Subscription