Thursday, 26 May 2016

Shapps defends claim that private rents are falling

The housing minister has insisted his claim that rents in the private rented sector are falling is correct after the issue was again raised in parliament.

Grant Shapps cited the latest English housing survey report as evidence that ‘rents in the private sector have reduced in real terms’.

The EHS figures show rents rose from an average of £156 a week in 2009/10 to £160 a week in 2010/11, net of service charges. Once inflation is taken into account this does work out as a small decrease in real terms.

However shadow housing minister Jack Dromey produced figures that show rents rose or stayed the same in 90 per cent of English local authorities. His figures were produced by the House of Commons library and are based on statistics from the Valuation Office Agency, part of HM Revenue and Customs.

Research body Full Fact has analysed the claims and concluded the politicians have both used very similar figures. ‘Either can be used to show a nominal terms increase in rents or a real terms decrease, and so both are correct within their own terms of reference,’ it said.

Inside Housing’s own research into rents found just 36 of 204 local authorities that responded to Freedom of Information Act requests had found any evidence of private sector rents falling as a result of changes to local housing allowance payments.

Our inquiries were prompted by claims made by prime minister David Cameron in January that private landlords were reducing rents in exchange for receiving LHA payments directly.

Housing minister Grant Shapps supported this position later in the month using figures from estate agency LSL Property Services. These showed a 0.8 per cent fall in rents compared with the previous month, although they were still up 4 per cent on the previous year.

LSL’s January figures showed a 0.1 per cent increase on December, and a 4.3 per cent annual rise.

Full Fact said the housing minister had ‘significantly misused’ the LSL data, which cannot be used to back up his claim ‘because the data is not seasonally-adjusted’.

Readers' comments (7)

Comments are only open to subscribers of Inside Housing

Already a subscriber?

If you’re already a subscriber to Inside Housing, your subscription may not be linked to your online account. You can link your subscription from within the My Account section of the website and clicking on Link My Account.

Not yet a subscriber?

If you don't yet subscribe to Inside Housing, please visit our subscription page to view our various subscription packages.

Have your say

You must sign in to make a comment

sign in register

Newsletter Sign-up



  • Government defends Pay to Stay after Lords defeats

    20 April 2016

    The government has pledged to ensure the social housing sector only supports those ‘who genuinely need it’, in response to a hat-trick of heavy defeats in the Lords on Pay to Stay.

  • Private rents increase 2.2% in Scotland

    10 November 2015

    Private rents have increased 2.2% in Scotland year-on-year, official statistics published today have revealed.

  • Scotland outlines plans to regulate private rents

    2 September 2015

    Scottish ministers have outlined plans to regulate private sector rents as part of new legislative proposals published yesterday.

  • Helm gets judicial backing in claim

    10 August 2015

    A High Court judge has ruled that a £9.75m valuation on land bought by 5,500-home Helm Housing Association was riddled with errors and failed to take key market information into account.

  • Landlord defends planned commune eviction

    3 July 2015

    A housing association has issued a lengthy-defence of its decision to move out residents of ‘communes’ in London, claiming it is simply ‘carrying out its responsibilities as a landlord’.

IH Subscription