Friday, 21 October 2016

Victory in shared care bedroom tax tribunal

A disabled man who spends two or three nights a week at his mother’s house occupies the property for bedroom tax purposes, a tribunal has found.

Margaret Rose, 60, had a bedroom in her property for her son Steven at her Holloway home, as well as a box room used to store equipment.

She was originally told she faced a benefits cut of £30-per-week because she under-occupied the property by two bedrooms.

But a judge at the Social Security and Child Support Tribunal ruled that one bedroom was occupied by Steven, who lives in full time care when he is not at his mother’s.

The tribunal also ruled the box room, which measured less than 50 square feet, should not be considered a bedroom as it was used to store equipment.

The case follows a number of first tier tribunal judgements on the bedroom tax which have found in favour of people with disabilities.

Lorna Reid, head of welfare at Islington law centre, said: ‘We think that this decision, even if it is not binding creates space for more challenges in shared caring cases.

‘We are delighted on behalf of the appellant and very, very pleased that we are starting to force the door open for further argument.’

Despite Ms Rose’s age she did not qualify for an exemption as she was not yet claiming a state pension.

It is understood Islington Council are not planning to appeal.

Related images

Readers' comments (10)

Comments are only open to subscribers of Inside Housing

Already a subscriber?

If you’re already a subscriber to Inside Housing, your subscription may not be linked to your online account. You can link your subscription from within the My Account section of the website and clicking on Link My Account.

Not yet a subscriber?

If you don't yet subscribe to Inside Housing, please visit our subscription page to view our various subscription packages.

Have your say

You must sign in to make a comment

sign in register

Newsletter Sign-up



  • Minimum bedroom size planned for shared PRS homes

    18 October 2016

    The government is planning to introduce new rules enforcing a minimum bedroom size in shared private rented sector homes.

  • Court rules bedroom tax is unlawful

    27 January 2016

    The bedroom tax unlawfully discriminates against domestic violence victims and disabled children, the Court of Appeal has ruled.

  • Bedroom tax tenants 'fail to downsize'

    18 December 2015

    Just 8% of tenants hit by the bedroom tax have moved to smaller properties, an official study commissioned by the government has found.

  • Tenant wins High Court victory

    24 November 2015

    A tenant has won a High Court case against a south London council in her bid to prevent an estate being demolished and rebuilt.

  • Stormont deal will nullify bedroom tax

    18 November 2015

    The bedroom tax will be introduced in Northern Ireland but fully mitigated for at least four years under an historic agreement to break political deadlock in the country.

IH Subscription