ao link
Twitter
Facebook
Linked In
Twitter
Facebook
Linked In

You are viewing 1 of your 1 free articles

On the naughty step with Lord Gary Porter

Lord Gary Porter is a maverick figure who doesn’t mind giving his own party a hard time on housing. Nathaniel Barker finds out more. Photography by Tom Campbell

Linked InTwitterFacebookeCard
Sharelines

On the naughty step with Lord Porter #ukhousing @garyporterlga

Lord Gary Porter talks housing, politics, the Right to Buy and more #ukhousing @garyporterlga

"There are a lot of people who wish I would shut up” we profile Gary Porter

On the naughty step with Lord Gary Porter

IH Meets is a series of profile interviews, where we meet a different figure within or connected to the housing sector

 

 

“It’s a stupid, negative policy,” declares Lord Gary Porter, concluding a passionate and lengthy rant about the introduction of fixed-term tenancies for council housing tenants.

One might be surprised to hear a Conservative council leader attacking the government – also Tory, of course – so forthrightly. But the Local Government Association (LGA) chair is different.

Mr Porter – he dislikes being referred to as ‘Lord’ – has garnered a reputation for being direct and straight-talking.

Mr Porter is a Conservative peer and a council leader in South Holland, Lincolnshire. He is also among the highest-profile critics of Conservative housing policy. After a Theresa May speech on planning in March, he attacked her failure to act on council borrowing powers, described as a savaging in The Independent.

He is also well known for an enigmatic Twitter account. For example, when new housing minister Kit Malthouse took on the role, he tweeted some typically forthright advice: “Fixing the housing crisis is like making a stool, it has three legs (private sector, councils and RSLs), bugger up one of the legs, you bugger up the stool. We have had 40 years of cutting bits off each leg then sticking books under to try to re-balance.”


READ MORE

Breaking the silence: a council insider shines a light on the homelessness crisisBreaking the silence: a council insider shines a light on the homelessness crisis
The beginner’s guide to funding Housing FirstThe beginner’s guide to funding Housing First
The benefits of using peer support models in shared housingThe benefits of using peer support models in shared housing

This may make Mr Porter look like a bit of a maverick, and indeed he can cause annoyance within the blue ranks for his outspoken nature. This is something he appears to enjoy.

“I get on the naughty step quite often over housing,” he says with a wry grin. But that doesn’t deter him. “On housing, what I say is right. That’s it. There’s no way of misrepresenting it, no way of not interpreting it properly, it just is right.”

Nevertheless, he does accept that “there are a lot of people who wish I would shut up”.

His verbal autobiography is succinct: “Born in Walthamstow, grew up in Stevenage, moved to Peterborough for a year. Lived in Lincolnshire for 34 years.”

Despite all that time in the East Midlands, Mr Porter has not lost his M25 twang; he drops his aitches so thoroughly that “house” must be preceded by “an”, as opposed to “a”.

Spalding, where he lives as leader of South Holland District Council and represents as a life peer in the House of Lords, is “the closest to the 1950s as you can get” he says with quiet fondness. He is clearly a man who likes things retro – his distinctive haircut, for instance, wouldn’t be out of place at an early Beatles gig.

In person, he manages to be simultaneously gruff and jovial: “I thought this was for Inside Housing, not Vogue,” he exclaims during the photoshoot. “Just get me next to a nice three-bed and be done with it.”

Originally a bricklayer – though he claims to have been sacked from every job he’s ever had – Mr Porter is also a self-declared “housing anorak”. He says the two aren’t linked, however.

“Don’t get me wrong, I like building them,” he muses. “Good fun, pays decent money. But housing is intrinsic to everything else we do, particularly good housing. If you’ve got sh*t housing you’ve got a problem.

“We should make the Right to Buy policy fit for purpose"

“And you haven’t just got a housing problem, you’ve got an education problem, you’ve got a health problem, anti-social behaviour problem, whatever. All of the bad things stem from bad housing, and the best way to fix any of those problems is to make sure as a fundamental that everybody’s got safe, secure, decent housing.”

He then launches into an impassioned thesis on the Right to Buy – Margaret Thatcher’s flagship policy to allow council tenants to buy their homes at a generous discount, a policy reinvigorated enthusiastically by David Cameron.

As of six weeks ago, the Chartered Institute of Housing called for the government to suspend the policy.

As a “massive fan” of the Right to Buy, Mr Porter believes that’s wrong.

“We should make the Right to Buy policy fit for purpose. So I should be able to set the discount locally to stimulate the market, not to reward avaricious grandchildren. I should keep 100% of the capital receipts so I can afford to build a replacement unit. Then what’s wrong with [it]?

“Do I care as a council whether you’re renting it off me, or whether Mr Bradford and Mr Bingley are paying me the mortgage money? If I’ve got the capital I can build a brand new house, I can take somebody else off that [waiting] list.”

With these changes, he insists, the Right to Buy would shift from being the biggest barrier to local authority housebuilding to becoming an accelerant. Yet ministers are perpetually reluctant to tweak their beloved policy in any way.

So why does Mr Porter, as a Conservative, think that is?

“No idea,” he raises his hands palms-up. “Any politician who’s got a brain cell can see that’s kind of a virtuous circle, because you’ve got somebody who’s become an owner; they’re safe, secure, haven’t had to move house, kids are in the same school, they’re happy. And I’ve got the money to build a nice new shiny house for somebody else on the list.”

The only way he could make this a more attractive prospect for ministers, he quips, would be to throw chocolate or sex into the mix.

Our conversation takes place a day after the government missed its own deadline to publish the Social Housing Green Paper by the summer parliamentary recess. The cynic in him means he’s not necessarily disappointed, though: “It depends what’s in it. If it’s full of stuff we don’t like they don’t need to bring it out at all.

Click here to read our Who’s Who in Local Authority Development List

“I’m optimistic in life, not in politics. I’d say there will be a few small moves in a positive way, and if the big stuff is missing then it will be another missed opportunity.”

Mr Porter has been praised for being prepared to stick his head above the parapet to criticise his party in this way – including by the judges of Inside Housing’s 2017 ‘Who’s Who in Local Authority Development’ list, which listed him as an ‘influencer’.

He surmises that some Conservatives’ apparent hostility towards him as a champion of mass council house building is related to the theory that those who rent vote red and those who own vote blue. But he dismisses this theory as “complete and utter pony”.

“The tenure you live in doesn’t determine who you vote for,” he maintains. “It might determine whether you bother to vote, but not who you vote for.

"And if you’re living in a cr*p house, one thing you won’t do is vote.”

Mr Porter came to politics during the 1997 general election, when he assisted with the successful Conservative campaign for the new seat of South Holland and The Deepings.

After that, he turned his energy on the council, helping the Tories take 20 seats at the 1999 local polls, becoming a councillor himself in a 2001 by-election. After the leader lost his seat at the 2003 elections, Mr Porter took up the mantle.

Now, the Conservatives hold a strong majority on the local authority and there is also what Mr Porter describes as a “very positive opposition”. “They don’t oppose it because the blue team thought of it. So that is a good thing and it helps me [at the LGA] because I’ve got a good reputation with my opposition,” he says.

Beyond housing, Mr Porter claims that the type of Conservative he is depends on the subject. What about, say, the NHS? “Given I’ve just had a triple bypass in St Thomas’ I’m a big fan of the National Health Service,” he laughs. “I don’t buy into the public-private argument, though… I don’t care who provides the healthcare as long as it’s good healthcare.”

And Brexit? “The LGA took a neutral position on Brexit. I’m the chair of the LGA, so I’ve got a neutral position on Brexit,” he answers carefully. “After I stop being chair people will know which way I voted.” (As a side note, South Holland was one of the most pro-Brexit areas in the country, with 73.6% voting to leave the EU.)

We don’t have too much longer to find out; under Conservative LGA group rules, he is unable to run for another term as chair and will leave his position in June 2019.

“I’ve got no plans,” he says of the future. “I’m going to have to be doing something, because I’ll do my head in if I’m sitting around on my backside not doing something.”

Whatever the something turns out to be, expect Mr Porter to remain a loud and independent voice when housing debates raise their head.

IH Meets

IH Meets

IH meets is a series of profile interviews, where we meet a different figure within or connected to the housing sector.

Interviews:

August 2018: Gary Porter

June 2018: Peter Denton

March 2018: Rebecca Evans

March 2018: Nick Walkley

March 2018: Sinead Butters

February 2018: Nicholas Coombe

January 2018: Eddie Hughes

November 2017: Melanie Onn

October 2017: Maxine Holdsworth

September 2017: David Orr

 

 

 

Linked InTwitterFacebookeCard
Add New Comment
You must be logged in to comment.
By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to the use of cookies. Browsing is anonymised until you sign up. Click for more info.
Cookie Settings